Airports have nothing to do with it.
Israel even provided arms for police in Gaza. The arms were promptly turned over to Hamas.
Hamas has no desire to establish peace--they get their funding by continued war.
-
Features
More Trouble In Israel
- Thread starter ZiprHead
- Start date
Airports have nothing to do with it.
Israel even provided arms for police in Gaza. The arms were promptly turned over to Hamas.
Hamas has no desire to establish peace--they get their funding by continued war.
untermensche
Contributor
The US is what allows Israel to continue it's brutal oppression and theft.
The US is what made Israel powerful.
The US is who has shielded Israel from UN sanctions for it's many crimes.
US citizens have some responsibility for what Israel has been doing these past decades.
You can't expect a nation not allowed to have a military to be able to secure it's borders.
untermensche
Contributor
Prove this.
Jarhyn
Wizard
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2010
- Messages
- 15,597
- Gender
- Androgyne; they/them
- Basic Beliefs
- Natural Philosophy, Game Theoretic Ethicist
Preferably with a story from the last 20 years... Granted if your logic is "Hamas runs the police, Isreal gave them to police, therefore initial sale was immediate hand-over to Hamas"... That's a face palm right there for you too.
DrZoidberg
Contributor
I think you're super deluded on this. The irony is on you. Not me
Harry Bosch
Contributor
This was very true, 15 years ago. Israel today is very independent. It has moved on from the US. It's economy is so strong that it now makes enough money that it can produce most of it's own weapons. It also is more popular today than the US. It was stunning to see an Israeli leader take such a side in the US elections favoring Trump. But the US does not have the influence that we once did:
https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/as-israels-dependence-on-u-s-shrinks-so-does-u-s-leverage/
"But that dependence may be ending. While Israel still benefits greatly from U.S. assistance, security experts and political analysts say that the country has quietly cultivated, and may have achieved, effective autonomy from the United States"
Swammerdami
Squadron Leader
This is quite doubtful. Most Westerners who hate Jews, hate Muslims as well. Hatred of Israel does NOT imply hatred of Jews. (Do you think hatred of Hamas implies hatred of Muslims?)
What makes you think they don't?
When a big bully is stealing from a small brat and pounding him until his bones break, the urgent need is to stop the bully. Until then, reprimanding the brat is not a priority.
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Nearly all of us agree that Israel has the right to defend itself. But it does NOT have the right to steal Palestinian land and to treat the Palestinians as subhumans to be humiliated. Even those of you who regard the Palestinians as subhumans must understand that such Israeli behavior does not promote peace.
untermensche
Contributor
Having a measure of independence after the US gave you hundreds of billions for free is something any nation would achieve.
Israel needs the US at the UN.
Otherwise it could be bled dry for all it's crimes.
Harry Bosch
Contributor
The Palestinians are screwed. But they have to take some responsibility for this. For whatever reason, they have always refused to develop an effective government that will speak for the Palestinian's benefit. They have always played the victim, relying on fellow Arab states to fight for their rights. This passive aggressive approach caused them to not act when offered good peace plans (Clinton plan, Oslo, and etc.). This approach seemed to work for a short time as the Arab states made peace with Israel contingent upon finding a good solution with the Palestinians. However, time is not on the Palestinian side. And as time has gone on and on: the Arab states have recognized that they have more immediate concerns: countering Iran; the wars in Yemen, Libya and Syria; and economics, diversifying their economy, and stability.
The Palestinians are weakened by their internal divisions, lack of strategy, and leadership made unpopular via bad governance and corruption. They mostly say just say "no". Just saying no isn't going to get them anything. And their allies, the Arab states, have moved on. Palestinians are no longer their priority. I'm still optimistic for the Palestinians. But they are going to have to start looking out for their own, rather than rely on allies or the UN to save them.
The Palestinians are weakened by their internal divisions, lack of strategy, and leadership made unpopular via bad governance and corruption. They mostly say just say "no". Just saying no isn't going to get them anything. And their allies, the Arab states, have moved on. Palestinians are no longer their priority. I'm still optimistic for the Palestinians. But they are going to have to start looking out for their own, rather than rely on allies or the UN to save them.
untermensche
Contributor
Palestinian leaders have been targeted and assassinated by Israel.
They have been isolated from the world, thrown off their land, and packed into little reservations.
Sound familiar?
They have been isolated from the world, thrown off their land, and packed into little reservations.
Sound familiar?
Harry Bosch
Contributor
That's a great idea! Let's just wait until the UN can fix this mess and help the Palestinians! I'm sure that the Palestinians won't have to wait for this to happen for another 73 years!
DrZoidberg
Contributor
I think you are being overly simplistic. The problem for the Palestinians is that the Arab nations around it are run by dictators who as fascists always do, have blamed internal problems on whatever is perceived as an external threat. They're all using the Palestinians as a PR weapon against Israel. The humanitarian crisis in Palestine is designed by especially Jordan. But also Iran, Syria and Egypt. They couldn't give less of a shit about the Palestinians. There's very little pan-Arabic unity. It's just something they pay lip service to while screwing over each other. All of Middle-East is ethnically fractured, with a multitude of hierarchies of allegiances, religious or otherwise.
Seeing this as a Arab vs Jew conflict is being played by the demagogues.
If the Arabs in the Middle-East truly hated the Jews as much as they say they do they would have crushed Israel back in the 50'ies and 60'ies. The only reason Israel survived was because they weren't trying that hard.
The Palestinians are truly fucked because they have zero support from Arabs in the Middle-East. The only money they ever get is money to Hammas (to fight Israel) and Fatah (to fight Israel).
They're doubly fucked because of deluded leftists who in a misguided attempt to help the Palestinians continue to support Fateh and Hammas, who only ever will make the conflict worse.
This meme isn't just a joke. That's literally what happens.
This doesn't exonerate Israel. It's very hard to support what Israel is doing. But I don't fault them for defending themselves.
Too many people have opinions on Israel who have no idea.
My ex-wife was Israeli.
But what's the relevance? The only fighting going on is because the Palestinians are trying to attack. If they would quit attacking they would have no border problem.
It's not my job to remember inconvenient facts you would prefer to forget. It was discussed at the time.
Whatever reason = all the Muslim money being poured into ensuring they don't form a viable state.
- Joined
- Oct 22, 2002
- Messages
- 41,893
- Location
- Frozen in Michigan
- Gender
- Old Fart
- Basic Beliefs
- Don't be a dick.
Open your eyes to what happens on the ground for Palestinians. No freedom of movement, you have to go through humiliating checkpoints just to go to the next village. Community punishment for crimes of individuals. Illegal Israeli settlers attacking Palestinians, destroying crops and literally poisoning community water wells. Torture in Israeli jails. Arrests simply for flying the Palestinian flag.
You only say the above because you're afraid to have a good, hard look at what is really happening because then you would have to admit you are wrong. I can't imagine these right-wingers if they had to actually live like this would not do the same. Hell those snowflakes freak out at having to wear a fucking mask.
untermensche
Contributor
An airport means the free flow of expertise and materials.
Palestinians can't secure their borders without external expertise or materials.
Which has nothing to do with the issue of whether they need an army.
And note that most of those attacks on the Palestinians are nothing of the sort. It's standard practice to blame the Jews for things whether or not they have any responsibility or even if there was an attack in the first place. (We are always seeing olive trees being attacked--but often in situations that make no sense. There's an unwanted plant that can easily be mistaken for an olive tree....)
Expertise isn't a problem.
Anything not of a military nature they can import now and few imports will go by air anyway, it's simply too expensive.