• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Progressives betray voters and back a Zionist speaker

Sigh. It should make you pretty happy that there is a big movement t to scuttle the speakership position for Jeffries, which I find very short sighted. Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
I've always found it pretty easy.
"I'm against genocide" - Anti-Zionism
"I'm just asking questions" - Anti-Semitic
Except considering "I'm against genocide" being anti-Zionist is buying into the antisemitic position that there was genocide in the first place. Zero actual evidence has been presented.

Skilled manipulators hide the actual deception in a layer before the supposed point of contention.
 
Sigh. It should make you pretty happy that there is a big movement t to scuttle the speakership position for Jeffries, which I find very short sighted. Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
I've always found it pretty easy.
"I'm against genocide" - Anti-Zionism
"I'm just asking questions" - Anti-Semitic
Except considering "I'm against genocide" being anti-Zionist is buying into the antisemitic position that there was genocide in the first place. Zero actual evidence has been presented.
Israeli IDF dug a makeshift small mass grave to hide an attack on an ambulance, which included burying the ambulance, in an attempt to hide the killings. Israel could have owned up to it. Said they messed up badly, they thought it was a threat or targets were hiding there.

Instead they literally tried to bury it and disappear civilians. While that isn't "genocide", it isn't remotely what a morally minded military would do.
Skilled manipulators hide the actual deception in a layer before the supposed point of contention.
I understand that you don't want to consider it Genocide, due to the connotation of the term. Fine. But people in Gaza have been living in tents for years now due to the widespread destruction and how unlivable portions of Gaza have been made by the IDF. Is Genocide the only low bar we are seeking to stay above?

Netanyahu has turned Gaza from a bad situation into an absolute crisis. They leveled buildings no one is willing to rebuild. Destroyed territory that can't be reconstructed due to lack of funding. The Arabs won't fund it, the Iranians won't fund it, the Palestinians can't fund it, the Israelis sure the heck won't fund it. The lives of hundreds of thousands of people have been uprooted for the next decade. \

That isn't "genocide", but it sure the heck isn't moral. And no, it isn't just Israel's fault, but Israel (the Netanyahu regime) has some level of blame here. And this is ignoring how this is going to create a hot bed for terrorist recruiting, making Israel no more secure than before.
 

If you can't see the big difference between a war in which the US was a direct participant, firing missiles and dropping bombs from day one, and one in which she was a mere bystander who may perhaps be dragged in at some future point, then I don't know how anyone can help you.
They are both proxy wars. The only difference in the case of Ukraine the US is financing that war so that Ukraine can die against Russia but in the case of Iran, US is cuckolded by Israel as its proxy for bombing Iran for them. More to the point, both wars involve US tax money being used to kill people.
We are not financing the war in Ukraine so Ukranians can die. We are financing the war so Ukranians can live--Russia has made it clear their intent towards Ukraine is genocide. They've done it before and they're doing it again in the areas they control.

Iran is a major nightmare. They have been killing probably millions and their oil production and geography has kept the world from reacting. The Felon was so stupid that he thought he could solve the problem with a few bombs. The days of surgical strikes disabling an enemy are over, we are back in the WWII realm where the only way to defeat a country is basically to destroy it. There is no path forward that stops Iran but leaves them a functional oil exporting nation.

Unfortunately, that means that either they take themselves out by revolution, or somebody takes the country down. And since taking the country down is horrific the cancer is allowed to grow.
 
Sigh. It should make you pretty happy that there is a big movement t to scuttle the speakership position for Jeffries, which I find very short sighted. Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
I've always found it pretty easy.
"I'm against genocide" - Anti-Zionism
"I'm just asking questions" - Anti-Semitic
Except considering "I'm against genocide" being anti-Zionist is buying into the antisemitic position that there was genocide in the first place. Zero actual evidence has been presented.

Skilled manipulators hide the actual deception in a layer before the supposed point of contention.
Don't derail the thread.
 
This thread was created by someone who loves listening to anti-Semitic white supremacists (Tucker Carlson etc).
I'm not anti-Semitic and neither is Tucker Carlson. Nor is anyone against Israel as a US ally.

What we are against is being Israel's cuckold and Washington being controlled and overrun by foreign influence.

We do not live in a Democracy if a foreign government tells our leaders what to do.
It's not that we are controlled by a foreign influence. It is controlled by the fact that we don't want the world blowing up. Israel is a nuclear power, fighting an existential war. They lose, the missiles fly. Keeping those missiles in their silos means making sure Israel doesn't fall.
 
While Israel has made mistakes in recent history, one'd be hard pressed to find any instance where Hamas-run Gaza did anything right. The decision to launch a war of aggression against Israel is certainly not doing something right. Neither is shooting rockets at Israeli cities, etc.
Depends on who is evaluating the situation.

10/7 was right from the viewpoint of those who decided to launch the 10/7 attack.
 
No they fucking aren't. Iran was attacked directly by the US military. That's not a proxy war, it's a fucking WAR.
The Shiitist Entity has been attacking the US since 1979. We should have put an end to it as soon as they took over our embassy.
I have no idea why you posted that as a reply to me; It is a complete non-sequitur.
No, he's pointing out that you're using a bad yardstick.

It's always start counting with the US or Israeli response, never counting from the action that triggered it. Derec is pointing out the trigger. Iran has been in a state of war with the US for it's entire existence. Taking the hostages was not an act of war because it wasn't done by the government--but when the radicals became the government and didn't immediately return the hostages it became an act of war. There has been no agreement ending the war, thus a state of war still exists.
 
This thread was created by someone who loves listening to anti-Semitic white supremacists (Tucker Carlson etc).
I'm not anti-Semitic and neither is Tucker Carlson. Nor is anyone against Israel as a US ally.

What we are against is being Israel's cuckold and Washington being controlled and overrun by foreign influence.

We do not live in a Democracy if a foreign government tells our leaders what to do.
It's not that we are controlled by a foreign influence. It is controlled by the fact that we don't want the world blowing up. Israel is a nuclear power, fighting an existential war. They lose, the missiles fly. Keeping those missiles in their silos means making sure Israel doesn't fall.
Your doomsday scenario is a fantasy. Israel is the only nuclear power in the region. There is no rational reason to expect other nuclear powers to unleash the arsenals to start WW3.

Israel is not under an existential threat at this time nor in this century. There is unjustifiable horrific terrorist attack was not an existential threat to the state of Israel. Israel’s response was much closer to an existential threat to Gaza than Hamas’s slaughter of civilians. US citizens have every right to question our funding of such responses. Especially since we are not funding the defense of a country that is undeniably under an existential attack.
 

If you can't see the big difference between a war in which the US was a direct participant, firing missiles and dropping bombs from day one, and one in which she was a mere bystander who may perhaps be dragged in at some future point, then I don't know how anyone can help you.
They are both proxy wars. The only difference in the case of Ukraine the US is financing that war so that Ukraine can die against Russia but in the case of Iran, US is cuckolded by Israel as its proxy for bombing Iran for them. More to the point, both wars involve US tax money being used to kill people.
I suppose if you use the word proxy enough times, you'll never be wrong. Using it for Russia's invasion of Ukraine is lunatic fringe level stuff. Given the US' presence on the world stage, it's probably not hard to connect its military hardware or funding to just about anything you want.

Russia amassed troops on Ukraine's border. Russia invaded driving straight for Ukraine's seat of power. The US and the entire world thought Ukraine would be toast in a matter of weeks. That it didn't happen that way and all the proxy aspects that now fit the scene is Russia's fault due to Russian ineptness and corruption. Sure it can look like a proxy war now in that this historic US foe is being depleted but that is completely Russia's doing.

The US and other western nations have been providing aid to a sovereign nation for its own self defense against Russia's territorial expansion. Nations do not get to invade other nations to create a buffer against a perceived enemy.
Russia committed an epic blunder here.

Previous situations have involved locals who weren't remotely trustworthy, our aid was limited. We trust that Ukraine will honor the limitations we put on weapons and will not divert them. This makes a huge difference in what we are willing to provide. And it's the best military deal the US has ever had--we get to bleed the bear without risking our people or risking WWIII. And weapons have value in deterring the enemy, not in their existence. So long as Russia loses proportionately more military capacity we end up stronger despite having fewer weapons.
 
No they fucking aren't. Iran was attacked directly by the US military. That's not a proxy war, it's a fucking WAR.
The Shiitist Entity has been attacking the US since 1979. We should have put an end to it as soon as they took over our embassy.
I have no idea why you posted that as a reply to me; It is a complete non-sequitur.
No, he's pointing out that you're using a bad yardstick.
But I am not. The contention is that the bombing of Iran is a "proxy war" for the US.

My response is that "proxy" does not apply if your military carries out direct attacks on the other side's military.

This is true regardless of who did what else to whom or when.
It's always start counting with the US or Israeli response, never counting from the action that triggered it.
I am not "counting" shit; I am saying that a proxy war is defined by indirect involvement, and that direct attacks mean thata given conflict is not (or is no longer) a proxy war; It's just a war.
Derec is pointing out the trigger. Iran has been in a state of war with the US for it's entire existence.
So what? That doesn't make it a proxy war; Nor prevent a proxy war from existing, so it is, as I said, a non-sequitur.
Taking the hostages was not an act of war because it wasn't done by the government--but when the radicals became the government and didn't immediately return the hostages it became an act of war. There has been no agreement ending the war, thus a state of war still exists.
Yes. And? How does any of that make the recent bombings of Iran by USAF and US Navy forces "proxy"??

You and Derec appear to be labouring under the misconception that "attack" is a derogatory word, and/or that only one side attacks the other during a war. This error seems to be driven by paranoia about being accused of responsibility.
 
Do you have a citation for Ms Nixon saying that only billionaires should be taxes?
"Should be taxes"?

Anyway, she certainly implied it. From the article:
Angie Nixon said:
And listen, I ain't made $105 billion, but you making me pay $12,000 to the feds? Like, really? That's what we're doing? And they already took some of the taxes away anyway. I paid over $10,000. It's just, it is crazy.
Is that really the type of person Democrats want in the US Senate, and not somebody like Alex Vindman?
So she DIDN'T actually say what you claim. Seems to me she's complaining about the disparity between what she has to pay and what the billionaire pays (which IS often nothing).
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Perhaps we don't, although there is this false idea that persists that billionaires pay no (or hardly any) taxes.
Wealth taxes are also a bad way to do that. Higher tax brackets and fewer loopholes would be a better idea.
There is also far too few billionaires for hyperfocus on them to be effective in increasing tax revenues in any meaningful way. I do not see why people like Nixon should not pay her own fair share just because she doesn't make "105 billion" as she puts it.
I genuinely believe that much or most student debt should be wiped out/written off. We have steadily been paying a shrinking share of the cost of public education, from pre-K through university.
While I do think we should invest more in education, I think much of the money we already invest is wasted. US does spend a lot on all levels of education, but we spend it in a very inefficient way, although that is a discussion for a different thread.
I also disagree that most student loans should be forgiven, especially for those who make enough to pay it back, like Nixon herself. She is just an entitled person who thinks rules should not apply to her.

I am very glad she lost, but dismayed that it was as close as it was, and that she will probably try again in 2028.
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.

My biggest issue with uber wealthy is that effectively, laws don’t apply to them, and indeed they and their corporations are able to skirt tax laws and other regulatory laws that apply to mere mortals.

IMO—No one should be above the law—including politicians and including wealthy people.

My next biggest issue with uber wealthy is that often, they accumulate their wealth through the labor of workers who are under compensated, including lack of meaningful benefits.


Our nation was supposedly founded on the principle that no one is above the law. We need to get back to that.

And we need to quit allowing unelected persons to call the shots about anything other than their own personal lives and their corporations plus voting if they are qualified citizens.

Ending Citizens United would be a good step to take.
What specific laws are being broken?
See Elon Musk. See Trump. See Epstein ( may he rot in hell). See Amazon and Walmart and Starbucks for illegal anti-union tactics. Those are the some of biggies.

Communities and states often ignore or grant exceptions to land use and environmental laws to large wealthy corporations who want to put an outlet into their communities.

Much smaller but persistent from times immemorial: Rich or well connected persons often get out of all sorts of tickets and arrests because they live in a particular neighborhood or have certain last names.
Yes I agree with you about Epson and Trump. But it’s hard for me to comment without knowing the specific laws that were broken. I do know a lot about economic development. There are some communities that are distressed and want better jobs. Do they create incentives to encourage that. Some communities are willing to trade short term decline in tax revenue for longer term growth in jobs. Oregons business taxes are high. Washington is much more open to business. I’d assume that if Oregon starts to decline in the future that they will be more open to incentives also.
Walmart. Walmart sucks off of the public teats in two obvious ways: Underpaying workers who have unpredictable shifts and often few benefits so that they must rely on public assistance to live and Walmart simultaneously gets huge property tax abatements and in the case of my town, the A-OK to drain wetlands for their gigantic concrete block and for driving local businesses ( who paid full freight on taxes) out of business.
 
Unfortunately nuanced language a policy to address our regressive tax code and oligarchy promoted by the extreme wealth of very few entities does not sell.
I didn’t finish this post earlier. Just ask “Pocahontas”. She’s very smart and wonky and it didn’t work even though she probably had the most sensible smart and sound grasp of things that needed to be done. But she was marked as just another commie lib dim.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
 
Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
Zionism means supporting the right of Israel to exist. Anti-zionists want to abolish Israel and replace it with yet another Arab, Muslim state.
FIFY. Strictly speaking, anti-Zionists are against Israel existence as a Jewish state. It's "replacement" is a separate issue.
Anti-Zionists are de facto tolerating of genocide.
 
On the other hand, if Nixon's annual income tax were equivalent to that which California billionaires pay - about .02% of their total wealth each year - at a mere six figures, that wouldn't come out to a particularly onerous bill. From the sound of it, she has income but very little actual wealth. It's likely to take her many years just to clear her debts, like most of us.
Taxing wealth is a bad idea. I know, I know, a lot of people think it's somehow horrible for people to have a lot of wealth... but a lot of those people also don't understand the difference between income and wealth, and haven't thought it all the way through.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Perhaps we don't, although there is this false idea that persists that billionaires pay no (or hardly any) taxes.
Wealth taxes are also a bad way to do that. Higher tax brackets and fewer loopholes would be a better idea.
There is also far too few billionaires for hyperfocus on them to be effective in increasing tax revenues in any meaningful way. I do not see why people like Nixon should not pay her own fair share just because she doesn't make "105 billion" as she puts it.
I genuinely believe that much or most student debt should be wiped out/written off. We have steadily been paying a shrinking share of the cost of public education, from pre-K through university.
While I do think we should invest more in education, I think much of the money we already invest is wasted. US does spend a lot on all levels of education, but we spend it in a very inefficient way, although that is a discussion for a different thread.
I also disagree that most student loans should be forgiven, especially for those who make enough to pay it back, like Nixon herself. She is just an entitled person who thinks rules should not apply to her.

I am very glad she lost, but dismayed that it was as close as it was, and that she will probably try again in 2028.
Closing tax loopholes + adding tax brackets for higher incomes = taxing the rich/billionaires.

My biggest issue with uber wealthy is that effectively, laws don’t apply to them, and indeed they and their corporations are able to skirt tax laws and other regulatory laws that apply to mere mortals.

IMO—No one should be above the law—including politicians and including wealthy people.

My next biggest issue with uber wealthy is that often, they accumulate their wealth through the labor of workers who are under compensated, including lack of meaningful benefits.


Our nation was supposedly founded on the principle that no one is above the law. We need to get back to that.

And we need to quit allowing unelected persons to call the shots about anything other than their own personal lives and their corporations plus voting if they are qualified citizens.

Ending Citizens United would be a good step to take.
What specific laws are being broken?
See Elon Musk. See Trump. See Epstein ( may he rot in hell). See Amazon and Walmart and Starbucks for illegal anti-union tactics. Those are the some of biggies.

Communities and states often ignore or grant exceptions to land use and environmental laws to large wealthy corporations who want to put an outlet into their communities.

Much smaller but persistent from times immemorial: Rich or well connected persons often get out of all sorts of tickets and arrests because they live in a particular neighborhood or have certain last names.
Yes I agree with you about Epson and Trump. But it’s hard for me to comment without knowing the specific laws that were broken. I do know a lot about economic development. There are some communities that are distressed and want better jobs. Do they create incentives to encourage that. Some communities are willing to trade short term decline in tax revenue for longer term growth in jobs. Oregons business taxes are high. Washington is much more open to business. I’d assume that if Oregon starts to decline in the future that they will be more open to incentives also.
Walmart. Walmart sucks off of the public teats in two obvious ways: Underpaying workers who have unpredictable shifts and often few benefits so that they must rely on public assistance to live and Walmart simultaneously gets huge property tax abatements and in the case of my town, the A-OK to drain wetlands for their gigantic concrete block and for driving local businesses ( who paid full freight on taxes) out of business.
This is what I was driving at in the thread I posted about what SpaceX is doing in Louisiana. In the name of jobs they get to dump negative externalities all over everything without consequence. They socialize the cost and privatize the profit. It isn’t a net benefit and never will be. In the long run, those few on the right side of that equation accumulate enough wealth that they become the defacto government and act everywhere with impunity. Just look at the laws Louisiana crafted to block torts against SpaceX.
 
Also worth noting that one can be anti-Zionist without being anti- Semitic. I’m quite concerned that this is being very muddled.
Zionism means supporting the right of Israel to exist. Anti-zionists want to abolish Israel and replace it with yet another Arab, Muslim state.
FIFY. Strictly speaking, anti-Zionists are against Israel existence as a Jewish state. It's "replacement" is a separate issue.
Anti-Zionists are de facto tolerating of genocide.
That is as valid as Zionists are de facto tolerating of genocide,
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
We tax wealth in the US in the form of estate taxes and property taxes. And have done so for decades.
 
We don’t tax billionaires enough and billionaires are very good at avoiding taxes.
Are you talking about someone who has a billion of income, or a billion of wealth?

Because if you're talking about wealth, that's not as good an idea as you think it is.
I'm talking about income. That said, I don't think we are appropriately taxing those who are deriving millions of dollars of income from $1B or more in wealth.
 
Back
Top Bottom