bilby
Fair dinkum thinkum
- Joined
- Mar 6, 2007
- Messages
- 44,401
- Gender
- He/Him
- Basic Beliefs
- Strong Atheist
But I am not. The contention is that the bombing of Iran is a "proxy war" for the US.No, he's pointing out that you're using a bad yardstick.I have no idea why you posted that as a reply to me; It is a complete non-sequitur.The Shiitist Entity has been attacking the US since 1979. We should have put an end to it as soon as they took over our embassy.No they fucking aren't. Iran was attacked directly by the US military. That's not a proxy war, it's a fucking WAR.
My response is that "proxy" does not apply if your military carries out direct attacks on the other side's military.
This is true regardless of who did what else to whom or when.
I am not "counting" shit; I am saying that a proxy war is defined by indirect involvement, and that direct attacks mean thata given conflict is not (or is no longer) a proxy war; It's just a war.It's always start counting with the US or Israeli response, never counting from the action that triggered it.
So what? That doesn't make it a proxy war; Nor prevent a proxy war from existing, so it is, as I said, a non-sequitur.Derec is pointing out the trigger. Iran has been in a state of war with the US for it's entire existence.
Yes. And? How does any of that make the recent bombings of Iran by USAF and US Navy forces "proxy"??Taking the hostages was not an act of war because it wasn't done by the government--but when the radicals became the government and didn't immediately return the hostages it became an act of war. There has been no agreement ending the war, thus a state of war still exists.
You and Derec appear to be labouring under the misconception that "attack" is a derogatory word, and/or that only one side attacks the other during a war. This error seems to be driven by paranoia about being accused of responsibility.