lpetrich
Contributor
Nicholas Kristof on Twitter: "We're tortured with bootstraps! The up-by-bootstraps narrative actually impairs upward mobility by substituting sanctimony for assistance. Fox News and others savaged @aoc for saying that bootstrapping is a fallacy, but she was right. My new column: https://t.co/8tLPWm1I8m" / Twitter
Opinion | Pull Yourself Up by Bootstraps? Go Ahead, Try It - The New York Times
Showing a cartoon of a lifeguard saying to someone drowning "If I toss it to you, you'll become dependent on it..."
Opinion | Pull Yourself Up by Bootstraps? Go Ahead, Try It - The New York Times
Showing a cartoon of a lifeguard saying to someone drowning "If I toss it to you, you'll become dependent on it..."
Complete with their whining "I didn't get any help." Some of them even used AOC herself as an example. But she recognizes that her success is not exclusively hers.Back in the 1800s, the expression “pull oneself up by the bootstraps” meant the opposite of what it does now. Then it was used mockingly to describe an impossible act.
An 1834 publication ridiculed a claim to have built a perpetual-motion machine by saying that the inventor might next heave himself over a river “by the straps of his boots.” An 1840 citation scoffs that something is “as gross an absurdity as he who attempts to raise himself over a fence by the straps of his boots.”
Yet this phrase has become part of America’s mythology and the centerpiece of our approach to help those left behind: We harangue them to lift themselves up by the bootstraps. When Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez this month dismissed bootstrapping at a congressional hearing as “physically impossible,” outrage reverberated across the conservative media world.