• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Bidengate Breaks... err... down

Hunter Biden will plead guilty to a gun charge and a misdemeanor tax charge. He will get probation.

The gun charge is a federal crime to punish drug users who also possess a gun. It is rarely charged because of all the marijuana users who would generate time-consuming paperwork for law enforcement and courts, but they had him dead to rights. I expect large numbers of Republicans who believe in gun rights to be outraged and immediately start agitating to have the charge dropped. Even if he's taking drugs, Hunter Biden should still have a right to own gun, shouldn't he? After all, we let drunks own guns and even carry them into bars in some places.
Yeah, it's a stupid charge. While I don't agree with the unlimited gun rights garbage the QOP is going for I think they took the easy route rather than the right route. What should be illegal is actually possessing (in hand or the like) a gun while impaired. Simply saying you can't have both makes it easier to charge (no need to prove the guy was impaired, and who cares about the rights of drug users) but isn't fair. (We've done the same thing with DUI--they made it easy to convict the guy who fell asleep at the wheel but the current law also convicts people who have "control" of the car but have no intent to drive. Say, sleeping it off in the parking lot of the bar.) (And I agree with the law allowing carrying a gun while in a bar--the designated driver. It's especially an issue in states that say no guns where alcohol is sold for consumption--which includes a lot of places that aren't alcohol businesses.)
 
The gun charge goes away after Biden jumps through some hoops. The other two misdemeanors carry up to a year in jail, and he may actually get jail time of a month or two, if the judge is as conservative as the prosecutor, David Weiss. Weiss was specifically kept on as a prosecutor because he was charged with digging up dirt on Hunter Biden, and the Biden administration didn't want to appear to cover it up. Trump had hoped that Weiss would find more serious charges surrounding the trumped up Burisma scandal and other dirt on Hunter Biden's activities, but these charges were the only thing they could find evidence to nail him with. Ironically, the Republican House committee was set up to target the Biden administration for "weaponizing government", but the reality is things like the David Weiss investigation that took over four years at a huge cost to taxpayers, only to recoup a couple hundred thousand dollars in lost tax revenue. And Congress is still spending a huge sum to keep investigating Hunter Biden.

:beatdeadhorse:
 
Justice for the elite, gotta love it.

I wouldn't call being the target of a 5-year federal criminal investigation just because he's the son of a president "justice for the elite". He agreed to plead guilty to these charges because he was technically guilty of the crimes, but such crimes are normally not brought (as in the case of the gun charge) or they are resolved by civil fines and penalties without involving any court (as in the case of the failure to report income). This is special treatment for the elite--specially harsh treatment.
 
Justice for the elite, gotta love it.
Name three people who have gone to jail under the same circumstances as Hunter.
One
Two
Three
Example 1
Turn out the cops were called at to the scene because the guy was acting erratically and threatening his neighbours. So nope.

Example 2
Congrats. This is legit and it's bullshit. Even worse, it appears federal prison is a great place for recidivism because Isca Johnson got arrested again earlier this year. I honestly wonder what his life would have been like if he wasn't arrested for such a bullshit charge in 2019.

Example 2
Each of the people charged were already under investigation from the DEA, had prior convictions and intended to distribute. Not the same.

So well done JH. One of your examples is similar to Hunter Biden. It's worth pointing out Isca Johnson looks slightly different to the other people you used as an example so it could reinforce Hunter was targeted because of some implicit bias. With Hunter it's obvious - he is Joe Biden's son so the Trump appointed prosecutor wanted to score points. I'm not sure what the bias was behind Johnson though.
 
Justice for the elite, gotta love it.
Name three people who have gone to jail under the same circumstances as Hunter.
One
Not equivalent.
Johnson’s arrest was part of "Operation Crime Driver", a joint federal, state and local law enforcement anti-violence initiative led by the District Attorney General’s Office for the 25th Judicial District, and conducted between February and May 2019, where law enforcement targeted offenders wanted on arrest warrants for violent criminal offenses in Tipton County, Tennessee. Johnson was among 6 defendants from the first phase of "Operation Crime Driver" to be indicted in federal court in October, 2019 for various drug and gun offenses. https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdtn/pr/operation-crime-driver-targets-violent-criminals-tipton-county
Close but no cigar.
Drug dealers. No evidence Hunter ever sold drugs. As a matter of fact, Hunter has never been arrested for drug possession.
 
So well done JH. One of your examples is similar to Hunter Biden. It's worth pointing out Isca Johnson looks slightly different to the other people you used as an example so it could reinforce Hunter was targeted because of some implicit bias. With Hunter it's obvious - he is Joe Biden's son so the Trump appointed prosecutor wanted to score points. I'm not sure what the bias was behind Johnson though.

In most of these rarely prosecuted cases where a weapon was found in connection with drug possession, the defendant had been involved in far more serious felony offenses, for example, violent crimes in the case of Isca Johnson. Drug distribution would also be something of a trigger, because those trafficking in narcotics are often involved in violence.

Hunter Biden did not fit the typical context in which that particular crime has been prosecuted in the past, but David Weiss had an ulterior motive. Like John Durham, he was specially charged with investigating Donald Trump's perceived political rival, Joe Biden. The hope was that Republican suspicions and claims about Biden would turn up some kind of crime that would validate them. Neither Durham nor Weiss came up with anythnig close to what was expected of them, and Durham had a particularly bad record on finding anything to prosecute. For Weiss, the felony gun charge and two misdemeanors, although small potatoes, was at least a victory conviction. Normally, the gun charge would not have been brought in his particular circumstances (11 days of gun possession and no hint of drug trafficking or violence), and the misdemeanor charges would have been settled with fines and perhaps other sanctions outside of court. From Hunter Biden's perspective, it was a way to end the long investigation by admitting to crimes he did commit without facing serious penalties, although he could still get some jail time, if the judge is another Republican wanting to get a little revenge on Joe Biden through his son's misbehavior.
 
Lying on a Federal Firearms Application is considered a major crime. Especially around here where people think that guns cause people to become criminals.

Drug users aren't allowed legally to own guns.

All three cases match.

But, in the real world...

Few Prosecutions For Lying On ATF Gun-Purchase Form


Lying on the form is a felony punishable by up to 10 years in prison. For being a user of unlawful drugs in possession of a firearm, the punishment is up to five years. The odds of being charged for lying on the form are virtually nonexistent. In the 2019 fiscal year, when Hunter Biden purchased his gun, federal prosecutors received 478 referrals for lying on Form 4473 — and filed just 298 cases. The numbers were roughly similar for fiscal 2020. At issue is when Biden answered “no” on the question that asks about unlawful drug use and addiction when purchasing a gun. Biden had been discharged five years earlier from the Navy Reserve for drug use and based on his 2021 memoir, he was actively using crack cocaine in the year he bought the gun. The data do not show how many people might have been prosecuted for falsely answering the question about active drug use. A 1990 Justice Department study noted how difficult it was to bring cases against people who falsely answer questions on the form, especially because there is no paper trail for drug abusers like there is for felons.

There you go again.
:beatdeadhorse:
 
Justice for the elite, gotta love it.
Name three people who have gone to jail under the same circumstances as Hunter.
I think Jason and the alt-right are mistaken here in judging what matters. It isn't that he is the President's son. It is he has access to very good lawyers. Like Trump (or OJ Simpson). Access to great lawyers is what helps people take charges that could lead to jail and become more about plea deals.

If Jason wants to be angry at anything, it'd be the upper crust establishment that is able to use their access to lawyers to get away with a boatload of stuff.
 
Justice for the elite, gotta love it.
Name three people who have gone to jail under the same circumstances as Hunter.
I think Jason and the alt-right are mistaken here in judging what matters. It isn't that he is the President's son. It is he has access to very good lawyers. Like Trump (or OJ Simpson). Access to great lawyers is what helps people take charges that could lead to jail and become more about plea deals.

If Jason wants to be angry at anything, it'd be the upper crust establishment that is able to use their access to lawyers to get away with a boatload of stuff.

The two-tiered justice system is something that upsets everyone except those in the top tier. I can't speak for what Jason's real motives are, but everyone else is talking about the fact that Hunter Biden is Joe Biden's son. The two misdemeanor charges and rare gun charge were the best deal that Trump's prosecutor, David Weiss, could get after search for crimes to pin on Hunter Biden for 5 years. They also brought closure for Hunter Biden's ordeal as the target of that investigation. He was always going to have to deal with the tax issues, and the gun charge seems likely to result in just probation, unless the judge has something against Biden.

If Jason is really concerned about the upper crust getting away with stuff, he may now want to turn his attentions to the Trump administration. There are still questions over why the Saudis gave Jared Kushner $2 billion six months after he left the White House. They could have bought a lot of Supreme Court justices with that kind of dough. Why Kushner? Of course, we can all still continue to be concerned about Hunter Biden's laptop in our spare time.
 
I think Jason is content with his self-appointed role as 'conscience of the liberal'.
 
They're barely even trying now.



the profile picture is not down by the balloon, It's up on the top left-hand corner, and the photo on this 2017 WhatsApp message is from 2022 from the south lawn of the White House. Bold and not bold text in the same message. They didn't even try.
 
It’s interesting that those signs (inaccurate imitation of screen, anachronistic photo) are the information needed to KNOW it is fake, and yet, so many people will see that evidence and still not know what is going on.
 
They're barely even trying now.



the profile picture is not down by the balloon, It's up on the top left-hand corner, and the photo on this 2017 WhatsApp message is from 2022 from the south lawn of the White House. Bold and not bold text in the same message. They didn't even try.


I doubt that image is actual evidence from an any official report, it's just a graphic someone reporting on the story made.

Doesn't matter anyway.


The transcript included a message Hunter sent to a business associate alluding to “sitting with his father,” seemingly suggesting that his father was aware of his business dealings. Shapley acknowledged the investigation didn’t turn up evidence to prove that, instead finding that it was likely untrue.
 
Back
Top Bottom