I give it to AM that not everyone who fails to get vaccinated and then contracts COVID totally deserves to die.
They just deserve to die more than those they infect deserve to die. On average, of course.
Neither deserves to die. Both deserve to live and learn and love!
It's a tragedy, pure and simple, insofar that some will not. That a failure to learn will produce an inability to live, and not only impacting themselves.
Tragedy is never pure and rarely simple. The ill and dieing Covid deniers of various stripes and practices are in themselves and in their story arcs, self-satire,.
The "don't punish them, how dare you" trope is like saying the someone who eats detergent pods doesn't deserve to be punished by getting sick, or that it's somehow unseemly to point out pointedly that their actions had predictable unpleasant consequences.