• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Drag Shows

Status
Not open for further replies.
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
 
I, too, find it impossible to understand. I kinda get FtM, obviously being a dude is better. But I don't have to understand it in order to grasp that other people can do whatever they want, if it doesn't involve me.
This isn't about people being free to do what they choose... as this is so much more fundamental. It is about accepting who they are. Accepting that our understanding on gender isn't nearly as simple as we have let on for millennia.
You can be kind to people without denying biological reality. Certainly, it’s much worse to deceive them?

 
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
Ah, so how often do female chimps become the troop alpha?
 
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
Ah, so how often do female chimps become the troop alpha?

In hyena packs, the packs are lead by an alpha female. And let's not mention Jordan Peterson's Lobsters.
 
I would like to see some Feminist Story Hours in libraies. And some Woke Story Hours in Libraries. Make them right wingers squeal!
 
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
Ah, so how often do female chimps become the troop alpha?

In hyena packs, the packs are lead by an alpha female. And let's not mention Jordan Peterson's Lobsters.
Right. Even the highest ranking hyena male is treated below the lowest ranking hyena female. Weird how nature strictly imposes the binary.
 
You seem unwilling to accept any other physical aspect to gender.
Gender is subjective and kinda meaningless.
If you use differing sexualities and mistake it for gender, I can understand your confusion here.
Nah, I’m just gender fluid.
You mean you are wasting our time now, simplifying responses into one sentence blurts that don't actually address whatever the other person has said. All the while, attempting to look witty and humorous, but failing.
 
You seem unwilling to accept any other physical aspect to gender.
Gender is subjective and kinda meaningless.
If you use differing sexualities and mistake it for gender, I can understand your confusion here.
Nah, I’m just gender fluid.
You mean you are wasting our time now, simplifying responses into one sentence blurts that don't actually address whatever the other person has said. All the while, attempting to look witty and humorous, but failing.
Whatever gender you claim to be, it does not change your biology. That’s fact. If you are born male, the coroner will find a male body.


Otherwise, the ease of these guys’ transmutation calls into question what we know of physical reality.

 
We should just listen to people. If they say they’re a dog, then they really are.


Flno_YyX0AQMmkk
 
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
Ah, so how often do female chimps become the troop alpha?
"Troop alpha" is not a term I have ever heard a chimpanzee use; you are imposing your cultural biases and beliefs onto chimp society without actually knowing all that much about chimp society. Chimp troops actually have both female and male leadership of a sort, but they don't understand the position in the same way you are implying. It isn't an office, claimed by an individual on the basis of history and tradition, but a social interaction heavily bounded by instinct. If a chimp does find itself in a situation where there is a dominant female and no obvious male contender, they'll adapt and kowtow to her just as they would a dominant male; we see this all the time in captive situations, as it is much more common in captivity to have a group composed of only adult females and juvenile males. But even in the wild, the equivalent of gender roles is not as clear cut as you're suggesting. For instance, chimp territorial wars have tended to be male only affairs, something huamn conservatives love to point out without much context. But it was recently observed the Tai troop in Cote d'Ivoire "breaks the rule" by having its dominant females fight as well. Except of course, there was never a "rule" in the first place, because that isn't how chimp society is organized to begin with.
 
We should just listen to people. If they say they’re a dog, then they really are.


Flno_YyX0AQMmkk

I've seen even more ridiculous things posted by Trumpistas, Evangelical Christians, and BLM supporters.

Humans are kinda stupid and very self centered. Ego cravings galore...

Is that news to you?
Tom

ETA ~What internet do you watch to find this sort of thing? Daily Mail? ~
 
As has been discussed, none of these are exactly "woman" because "woman" is more a holistic culture built around rather than  of the actual tendency towards differences between people.
Is this true for all other female primates and mammals? If not, why not?
It is not. Because they have no such concept of gender in the first place. There are no real assigned gender roles in chimp society, and if an individual within a troupe wants to do something that a religion-blinded human would find offensive due to their assigned gender- like a male chimp spending too much time caring for a child, or getting a hand job from another male - there are no social barriers to their doing so. We know this, because we've seen both happen in the wild on many occasions.
Ah, so how often do female chimps become the troop alpha?
"Troop alpha" is not a term I have ever heard a chimpanzee use; you are imposing your cultural biases and beliefs onto chimp society without actually knowing all that much about chimp society. Chimp troops actually have both female and male leadership of a sort, but they don't understand the position in the same way you are implying. It isn't an office, claimed by an individual on the basis of history and tradition, but a social interaction heavily bounded by instinct. If a chimp does find itself in a situation where there is a dominant female and no obvious male contender, they'll adapt and kowtow to her just as they would a dominant male; we see this all the time in captive situations, as it is much more common in captivity to have a group composed of only adult females and juvenile males. But even in the wild, the equivalent of gender roles is not as clear cut as you're suggesting. For instance, chimp territorial wars have tended to be male only affairs, something huamn conservatives love to point out without much context. But it was recently observed the Tai troop in Cote d'Ivoire "breaks the rule" by having its dominant females fight as well. Except of course, there was never a "rule" in the first place, because that isn't how chimp society is organized to begin with.
Eh, how many male chimps give birth? How may males chimps pretend to give birth; or pretend to nurse? That's really the issue. I mean, has an amorous alpha male ever confused a male chimp for female?
 
We should just listen to people. If they say they’re a dog, then they really are.


Flno_YyX0AQMmkk
Ignoring trolling, the poster could easily have meant she has had six dogs FOR PETS and been in only two long-term relationships. IE she's had dogs longer than guys. Not that she was fucking dogs. The response to her post also implies that this was a JOKE.

And somehow you have built your worldview partially based on something you didn't get.
 
I've seen even more ridiculous things posted by Trumpistas, Evangelical Christians, and BLM supporters.

Humans are kinda stupid and very self centered. Ego cravings galore...

Is that news to you?
No doubt. There was a guy who had sex with his car. But that didn't make him a car.
 
We should just listen to people. If they say they’re a dog, then they really are.


Flno_YyX0AQMmkk
Ignoring trolling, the poster could easily have meant she has had six dogs FOR PETS and been in only two long-term relationships. IE she's had dogs longer than guys. Not that she was fucking dogs. The response to her post also implies that this was a JOKE.

And somehow you have built your worldview partially based on something you didn't get.
Oh, no. She seems quite serious.


Yet, you deny her self-ID? If a man can become a woman, and a white person can become black, then there really is no basis to deny that a human woman can became a female dog.
 
Some fat bloke called Brian won the Greater Derry Beauty pageant;

A local beauty pageant is attracting ample mockery on social media after a trans-identified male was crowned the winner of the competition and awarded a scholarship intended for young women. Brían Nguyen, 19, was awarded the crown in the Miss Greater Derry pageant, held on November 8 in the Greater Derry area of New Hampshire. The competition is a locally-run event under the national Miss America series of pageants. In addition to winning the crown, Nguyen will receive the Miss Greater Derry Scholarship, a financial award established to support young women.

News

I hate to be mean but describing Brian as a beauty is a fucking stretch of epic proportions. Never the less, "she/he" won and will receive some sort of scholarship.



See if you can tell which contestant is Brian.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom