Toni
Contributor
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2011
- Messages
- 20,890
- Basic Beliefs
- Peace on Earth, goodwill towards all
I’m absolutely certain of my friend’s English skills and accent as I mentioned, she spoke English along with her maybe language from childhood, attended university and graduate school at very his universities in the US abd taught at American universities for over 30 years, as well as being active and in leadership positions in a number of organizations, was a faculty advisor for university organizations, founded an educational foundation in our community and has friends literally from all over the world, with English being the common language. I am aware that there are those Americans who, upon seeing someone who is not Caucasian, imm sisterly have a problem with their accent—no matter where anyone was born and raised. Any accent that she has is very slight and only would be a problem for someone who wanted it to be a problem.The question is how much. Saying they face "discrimination" is not an adequate justification for affirmative action! Same as "pain" isn't a justification for morphine.You'd be naive to believe that persons of color, women and LGBTQA+ persons today do not suffer from discrimination based on their skin color, gender and sexual orientation. Certainly plenty of people who are or who resemble (to some people) people who are Hispanic or Middle Easterners can face discrimination, as can those who are or who are perceived to be Jewish or Palestinian/Muslim/Arab. Depending on where you live, Native Americans can face significant discrimination. Asians face discrimination.You're talking about giving people today extra access to make up for the fact that their grandparents didn't have access.By giving people previously excluded because of their race, gender or country of origin from the pool of applicants access to educational and career opportunities they would not have had prior to affirmative action.
Sure it really was race? You're close to her, you're used to understanding her. I barely hear my wife's accent--but when put to an objective test she has a lot of trouble with Alexa.Because I'm white and many of my friends and acquaintances are academics or academic adjacent, it's pretty easy for me to think that at least in my little world, there is no more discrimination but unfortunately, that is absolutely untrue. I believe it was in this thread where I described a dear friend who is Asian and who has spoken English since early childhood, attended university and grad school in the US and who taught in academia for decades routinely had students complain to admin. that they had trouble understanding her excellent English (as in: barely any accent at all).
And someone not lasting a year is proof it's discrimination???For the most part, admin backed her up but if you think that does not take a toll, then you are quite mistaken. The same with her husband, and a lot of faculty I know personally. I've watched newly hired black administrators not last more than one academic year, quite recently. Racism, sexism and discrimination are alive and well.
Someone who simply assumes they are a DEI hire is a bigot. But someone who considers them suspect until proven competent is simply responding to the fact that there are DEI hires.Complaining that anyone who is female or a person of color was an AA --or more recently, a DEI hire is actually a form of bigotry and discrimination.
It's impossible for it to be all in the past so long as we continue to enforce discrimination in the form of affirmative action.It would be lovely if it were all in the past but it's not.
1) You're taking a guilty-without-evidence approach, assuming that anything that could be interpreted as discrimination. But you're not considering that there might be other factors.It may well be the case that it is time to sunset Affirmative Action laws. I don't know the answer. But I do know that discrimination happens every single day in my small community--in a mostly blue state.
2) Affirmative Action inherently causes discrimination and thus it causes backlash. Thus the problem can never be solved so long as the laws exist. Especially when you fail to consider things like a criminal record excluding people from a lot of things. The population from which one can draw doesn't match up with the racial distribution in many cases.
I have no problem with going after actual discrimination. But statistical discrepancies are never more than a reason to take a quick look. A quick look that doesn't require mounting a defense so it doesn't impose an undue cost on a business.
I’ve worked for/with people from all over the world, from every continent except Antarctica and have friends and neighbors from all over as well. Yes, I’m accustomed to accents —and I definitely know people with much heavier accents, including from Australia.
How much discrimination and racism must one suffer to be entitled to relief?
Asking on behalf of butt hurt white men who cannot cope with seeing people who are t white and/or male compete for on equal footing and win and succeed at jobs they thought were by rights theirs.
Here’s sometii go by you may get: Trump has more than once mentioned immigrants taking black jobs. He may be re-elected POTUS because that’s just how common that sort of racist crap that is.