• Welcome to the new Internet Infidels Discussion Board, formerly Talk Freethought.

Russian Invasion of Ukraine - tactics and logistics

The report itself was produced by the British government, which might wish to avoid openly criticizing Hungary.
The Royal United Services Institute isn't the British Government; It's an explicitly politically independent body set up to provide expert advice to government and armed forces in the UK. It's funded as a registered charity.
 
Among the deliveries of military equipment to Ukraine is something called a "ghost drone", whose capabilities are not much talked about. Apparently, it is related to the so-called "jackknife kamikazi drones" and were manufactured specifically for use in Ukraine.

Mystery drone: How the Air Force fast-tracked a new weapon for Ukraine

I think the switchblade drones are probably useless. They were delivered long ago, so they should've seen action, but there haven't been any mention of successful strikes using them that I've seen.

The smaller switchblade is basically just a flying hand grenade. The bigger one packs a punch similar to Javelin, but it's still a propeller plane that flies way slower than a missile. Probably too easy to shoot down before they reach their target.

US military suppliers are just using this war to test their wares. The "ghost drone" probably falls into the same category.
 
Among the deliveries of military equipment to Ukraine is something called a "ghost drone", whose capabilities are not much talked about. Apparently, it is related to the so-called "jackknife kamikazi drones" and were manufactured specifically for use in Ukraine.

Mystery drone: How the Air Force fast-tracked a new weapon for Ukraine

I think the switchblade drones are probably useless. They were delivered long ago, so they should've seen action, but there haven't been any mention of successful strikes using them that I've seen.

The smaller switchblade is basically just a flying hand grenade. The bigger one packs a punch similar to Javelin, but it's still a propeller plane that flies way slower than a missile. Probably too easy to shoot down before they reach their target.

US military suppliers are just using this war to test their wares. The "ghost drone" probably falls into the same category.
The switchblade is very effective in scouting (they can scout for 20 minutes or so) and then dive into targets. They won't take out a tank, but are very effective against trucks and transports. The larger units are for tanks and armored transports. I suspect that the ghost drone is probably stealthy. You'd think that drones being slow would be easy to spot and shoot down. But doesn't seem to be the case. They seek infared heat and are deadly at night.
 
The report itself was produced by the British government, which might wish to avoid openly criticizing Hungary.
The Royal United Services Institute isn't the British Government; It's an explicitly politically independent body set up to provide expert advice to government and armed forces in the UK. It's funded as a registered charity.

A technical distinction without a significant difference. It may be a British think tank with an "international perspective", but it is a British institution that has very close ties to the British government and helps the government to strategize and form foreign policy. The US government has similar think tanks with similar connections to the US government. All of these are funded by corporations and individuals who get tax breaks for supporting them. Russia also uses such think tanks. The report itself was released for public consumption, but these think tanks also do classified work. Note that they explicitly claimed not to be able to reveal all their sources. The release of that report was likely contingent on being vetted by the British government.
 
Among the deliveries of military equipment to Ukraine is something called a "ghost drone", whose capabilities are not much talked about. Apparently, it is related to the so-called "jackknife kamikazi drones" and were manufactured specifically for use in Ukraine.

Mystery drone: How the Air Force fast-tracked a new weapon for Ukraine

I think the switchblade drones are probably useless. They were delivered long ago, so they should've seen action, but there haven't been any mention of successful strikes using them that I've seen.

The smaller switchblade is basically just a flying hand grenade. The bigger one packs a punch similar to Javelin, but it's still a propeller plane that flies way slower than a missile. Probably too easy to shoot down before they reach their target.

US military suppliers are just using this war to test their wares. The "ghost drone" probably falls into the same category.
The switchblade is very effective in scouting (they can scout for 20 minutes or so) and then dive into targets. They won't take out a tank, but are very effective against trucks and transports. The larger units are for tanks and armored transports. I suspect that the ghost drone is probably stealthy. You'd think that drones being slow would be easy to spot and shoot down. But doesn't seem to be the case. They seek infared heat and are deadly at night.
The real test is how effective they are on the battlefield. So far, I haven't found any footage or mention of switchblade being used in action. "Phoenix Ghost" could be more effective due to its longer range and fly time, for reconnaissance if nothing else.
 
The real test is how effective they are on the battlefield. So far, I haven't found any footage or mention of switchblade being used in action. "Phoenix Ghost" could be more effective due to its longer range and fly time, for reconnaissance if nothing else.
I don't think that we can reliably know when either the switchblades or the ghosts are successful in blowing up targets. That information may well be classified. The government only announced their deployment because of all the criticism coming from Ukraine and the news media about how much effort the government is making to help Ukraine. I'm sure that there are plenty of activities that we don't know about and may never learn about. What we hear tends to be what is announced or intentionally leaked. If and when one of those drones fails to destroy itself and is captured by the Russians, they will probably trumpet it to the world, complete with pictures, just as we have done with captured equipment abandoned and left behind by retreating Russian troops.
 

Ukrainian "army" blow themselves up on their own mine.
They spot the first mine and even took a selfie with it.
Could not avoid the next one. Mines are their own. The guy is laughing at the fact that other guy is dying.

Same story with sea mines. Early on they put mines around Mariupol. That complicated their evacuation by the sea. Now Azov&Co are stuck there.

Ukrainian (or russian it's not clear) tank kills bunch of ukrainian soldiers taking selfies, from no more than 30 meters distance.
 
Last edited:

Ukrainian "army" blow themselves up on their own mine.
They spot the first mine and even took a selfie with it.
Could not avoid the next one. Mines are their own. The guy is laughing at the fact that other guy is dying.

Same story with sea mines. Early on they put mines around Mariupol. That complicated their evacuation by the sea. Now Azov&Co are stuck there.

Ukrainian tank kills bunch of ukrainian soldiers taking selfies, from no more than 30 meters distance.


As far as I can tell from this video, which originated with "Belarus Today" and got distributed on Youtube (although ordinary Belarusians would not have access to Youtube), does not say anything about the mine being Ukrainian. The sources say that the "found" the mine and disarmed it, made a selfie of the disarmed bomb, and then subsequently got blown up by a different mine when their vehicle drove over it. Barbos seems to have embellished the story a bit. In his account of the "special operation", the Ukrainians are constantly destroying their own property, blowing themselves up, killing their own civilian population, etc., etc.--a neverending supply of Nazis slowly destroying themselves while Russians post videos to show what they are doing. On the Youtube page, there is this statement:

Sources of the video report that the sabotage and reconnaissance group of the Armed Forces of Ukraine was driving through the field. They found a mine, cleared it and made a solemn video recording. A hundred meters later, their car was blown up by another mine. Some died immediately,

Of course, we don't know how accurate the description was, since the video was obviously put out for propaganda purposes. The Youtube page is full of comments that support the ridiculous Kremlin-manufactured conspiracy theory that Russia is fighting "Nazis" rather than invading a neighboring country. They can't yet call it a "war", but the British report suggests that May 9 will be the likely threshold for the Orwellian propaganda to signal that it is an official "war". The point of all this gaslighting is to prepare the Russian public for a long, drawn-out conflict resulting in the full subjugation of Ukraine by the end of the summer.
 
The switchblade is very effective in scouting (they can scout for 20 minutes or so) and then dive into targets. They won't take out a tank, but are very effective against trucks and transports. The larger units are for tanks and armored transports. I suspect that the ghost drone is probably stealthy. You'd think that drones being slow would be easy to spot and shoot down. But doesn't seem to be the case. They seek infared heat and are deadly at night.
The real test is how effective they are on the battlefield. So far, I haven't found any footage or mention of switchblade being used in action. "Phoenix Ghost" could be more effective due to its longer range and fly time, for reconnaissance if nothing else.
The lack of mention doesn't prove they aren't being used--you want to keep tactics secret to the extent you can.

Everyone will recognize a Javelin or Stinger attack, there's no reason to hide them and every reason for Ukraine to show them--yes, they're being put to good use, send more.

A drone, however, Moscow is simply going to know something went boom. Ukraine is better off not telling how they found the target, or how the target was destroyed--the more information Moscow has the more likely they will be able to counter the tactic next time.
 
The lack of mention doesn't prove they aren't being used-
Russian news reported the use of switchblade... against a tank.
Unfortunately, no link to a source again, but that is to be expected with barbos. If someone has the energy and desire to search Russian media, a suitable link can probably be found. Eventually, Russia will capture one of these drones carrying a warhead that fails to detonate, if they haven't already. These drones are cheap and easy to produce, so maybe Russia will develop their own versions. In a sense, this war could be labeled "The Attack of the Drones". Drone warfare has become a major battleground tactic.
 
"Amateurs talk strategy, professionals talk logistics." - General Omar Bradely.

One of Russia's biggest failures in this war has been the bungling of logistical support to carry out battle tactics inside of a huge country. Putin has impressed himself by buying a boatload of fancy new weapons systems that end up not amounting to much in terms of conquering and occupying a huge country like Ukraine. This article is about the trucks that supply the frontline troops and how Russia has simply failed to maintain them properly. This has been a big factor in their rather embarrassing performance against a smaller, more poorly equipped military. Where Russia has made big gains has been in areas where they have shorter, more easily defended supply lines.

What images of Russian trucks say about its military's struggles in Ukraine
 
In any case, you people need to update your debate manuals. Russian forces changed their tactics long time ago. Crimea style Blitzkrieg clearly did not work and current tactics is to cause maximum damage to the enemy at minimum cost. Time is not an issue. Putin cancelled direct assault of AzovSteel catacombs and ordered just waiting these people out.

I admit Crimea style Blitzkrieg was a long shot which did not work.
 
In any case, you people need to update your debate manuals. Russian forces changed their tactics long time ago. Crimea style Blitzkrieg clearly did not work and current tactics is to cause maximum damage to the enemy at minimum cost. Time is not an issue. Putin cancelled direct assault of AzovSteel catacombs and ordered just waiting these people out.

I admit Crimea style Blitzkrieg was a long shot which did not work.

So funny. When I first started this thread, I alledged that Russian was really just doing this because Putin wanted a land bridge to Crimea and water. That's what the Russians are focused on now. Your side is killing lots of people and blowing everything up. But the Russians are losing. I feel terrible for the Ukrainians who have been very brave and resolute. But the Russian imperialism has absolutely united Nato and Eastern Europe.
 
In any case, you people need to update your debate manuals. Russian forces changed their tactics long time ago. Crimea style Blitzkrieg clearly did not work and current tactics is to cause maximum damage to the enemy at minimum cost. Time is not an issue. Putin cancelled direct assault of AzovSteel catacombs and ordered just waiting these people out.

I admit Crimea style Blitzkrieg was a long shot which did not work.
Barbos: I'd be curious to hear from you if you think that there is any chance of a compromise between Russia and the west. What do you think it would take for the Russian people to accept Russian troops returning home?
 
Among the deliveries of military equipment to Ukraine is something called a "ghost drone", whose capabilities are not much talked about. Apparently, it is related to the so-called "jackknife kamikazi drones" and were manufactured specifically for use in Ukraine.

Mystery drone: How the Air Force fast-tracked a new weapon for Ukraine

I think the switchblade drones are probably useless. They were delivered long ago, so they should've seen action, but there haven't been any mention of successful strikes using them that I've seen.

The smaller switchblade is basically just a flying hand grenade. The bigger one packs a punch similar to Javelin, but it's still a propeller plane that flies way slower than a missile. Probably too easy to shoot down before they reach their target.

US military suppliers are just using this war to test their wares. The "ghost drone" probably falls into the same category.
The switchblade is very effective in scouting (they can scout for 20 minutes or so) and then dive into targets. They won't take out a tank, but are very effective against trucks and transports. The larger units are for tanks and armored transports. I suspect that the ghost drone is probably stealthy. You'd think that drones being slow would be easy to spot and shoot down. But doesn't seem to be the case. They seek infared heat and are deadly at night.
The real test is how effective they are on the battlefield. So far, I haven't found any footage or mention of switchblade being used in action. "Phoenix Ghost" could be more effective due to its longer range and fly time, for reconnaissance if nothing else.
No, the real test is how effective they are hitting supply lines because war is more about the shaft of the spear than the tip.
 
In any case, you people need to update your debate manuals. Russian forces changed their tactics long time ago. Crimea style Blitzkrieg clearly did not work and current tactics is to cause maximum damage to the enemy at minimum cost. Time is not an issue. Putin cancelled direct assault of AzovSteel catacombs and ordered just waiting these people out.

I admit Crimea style Blitzkrieg was a long shot which did not work.

So funny. When I first started this thread, I alledged that Russian was really just doing this because Putin wanted a land bridge to Crimea and water. That's what the Russians are focused on now. Your side is killing lots of people and blowing everything up. But the Russians are losing. I feel terrible for the Ukrainians who have been very brave and resolute. But the Russian imperialism has absolutely united Nato and Eastern Europe.

When Putin's second invasion of Ukraine started in February, Finland and Sweden were still a long shot for ever becoming NATO members. Barbos ridiculed the idea that either country would join, and Putin made all sorts of threatening noises. Now, both countries will apply to join at the same time in the middle of May. So much for Putin's bullying tactics.

Live updates | Report: Sweden, Finland to apply to NATO

Three NATO warships have just docked in Finland. Jayjay will likely have more to say about this breaking news.

NATO Warships Arrive at Finnish Port for Training Exercises

 
When Putin's second invasion of Ukraine started in February, Finland and Sweden were still a long shot for ever becoming NATO members. Barbos ridiculed the idea that either country would join, and Putin made all sorts of threatening noises. Now, both countries will apply to join at the same time in the middle of May. So much for Putin's bullying tactics.

Live updates | Report: Sweden, Finland to apply to NATO

Three NATO warships have just docked in Finland. Jayjay will likely have more to say about this breaking news.

NATO Warships Arrive at Finnish Port for Training Exercises

Seems to be a standard anti-mining exercise that's been planned for a year in advance. These are not unique and similar exercises have been happening in previous years at least since 2018.
 
Back
Top Bottom