• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Which movie did you watch today and how would you rate it?

If it has science and the story is fiction......
How much science is there in Star Wars? Is Star Wars sci-fi?

It's a romantic adventure story - farm boy discovers prowess as a swordsman, defeats the black knight and destroys his castle, gets the princess (who, in fine aristocratic tradition, is also his sister).

It's set in the past. ("A long time ago, in a galaxy far, far away..." is the opening statement).

There are technologies that are beyond our present ability, but these are basically just magic, per Clarke's Law, with no explanation of how they might work, or what (if any) science underlies them. Some are directly contrary to science as we understand it; And some are not even technological - "The force" is pure supernaturalism.

So the ONLY thing that makes Star Wars sci-fi is that it's set in spaaaaace. But few people would say that it's NOT sci-fi.
 
Abraham Lincoln vampire hunter isn’t a historical movie just because Lincoln was a historical figure.
And the same is true of Braveheart, despite William Wallace being an historical figure.

Indeed, it probably makes more sense to classify Braveheart as science fiction than as historical. It did showcase some allegedly novel military technologies, after all.
 
The End of Oak Street

Family from early 1980s somehow gets transported to some place where dinosaurs are. Chaos ensues.

This one's getting a ton of hate, but it's misplaced. It's not meant to be taken seriously, it's meant to be fun, and it succeeds at doing exactly that. It's not some 2+ hour endurance contest meant to convey anything deep or contain breakthrough ideas. It reminded me of the films of pre-streaming days when you went to the movies to see one-off flicks like this and weren't furious that it wasn't the next Big Thing in some shamelessly whored-out IP.

6/10
Both my wife and I liked it.
 
If it has science and the story is fiction......
But a lot of these don’t “have science”. Just being in space or using advanced tech isn’t science.

Abraham Lincoln vampire hunter isn’t a historical movie just because Lincoln was a historical figure.

Without science it's merely fiction set in an imaginary futuristic setting. Fantasy, not science fiction? Fantasy novels, fantasy movies, fantasy TV shows.
 
Science-fantasy.
I am a fan of 'hard' Sci-fi. (Asimov, Larry Niven)
But there just isn't enough produced to fill a bookshelf.
Most librarys, bookstores, vid streamers, etc. lump it into the category "Science fiction/fantasy".
I know a bunch of SF fans that love "Game of Thrones". Very few of us are science purists.
Decades ago ALL SF was considered Fantasy.
 
I watched a movie today that I knew would be bad but it's far worse than I expected

Titanic II. I mainly wanted to watch it for the special effects but they were bad also.

The plot was stupid. (A tsunami out in the middle of the Atlantic causes an ice burg to fly up out of the water and crash into the ship at 200 miles an hour)

The sets were stupid (There are no concrete tunnels in ocean liners)

Special effects CGI was pretty poor.

The acting was bad (Really bad)

 
Back
Top Bottom