They are part of the same left-wing ideology of discriminating against certain group in other to promote others.
They are the best predictor of future academic performance. MCAT more so than GPA because of very different classes different premeds might take and because of very different grading between undergrad schools. A 3.9 at Clayton State University may be equivalent of 3.2 at Georgia Tech for example even when same classes are taken.
In any case, there is no reason to require lesser academic performance of black or Hispanic students compared to white and Asian ones.
It's a different example, of course; but one that demonstrates the same ideology of discriminating by sex and race.
I do not think selection of SCOTUS justices should be based on making the court composition match that of the population. But even if you wanted to do that, how does representation require that two out of nine justices must be black? That is 22%, significantly more than the share of blacks in US population (14%). 11% is a better reflection of the population than 22%.
People from all groups should be considered, and the best one chosen. The problem with Biden's Corrupt Bargain was precisely that everybody who was not part of a relatively small group was not considered for the seat. Biden agreed (in order to buy Jim Clyburn's support) to not consider anybody Asian for the position either. Or anybody with a penis. Biden was in effect telling 93% of the population: "fuck you, you don't matter".
Who is Amy Coney Bryant? If you mean
Amy Coney Barrett, she does have extensive and varied legal experience as well.
From her wiki page:
- Clerked for judges, including Justice Scalia
- Worked in private practice, and worked on SCOTUS "Bush v. Gore" case during that time
- Law professor
- Judge on a US Court of Appeals
You and I may not disagree with many of her positions, but she is eminently qualified and has a lot of varied experience.
And I am not saying that KBJ is not qualified. She obviously is.
I am saying that Biden should not have restricted his search to black women only. I do not see how that is in any way defensible.