Johnson’s office handled Arbery’s case only briefly, but she quickly drew scrutiny — in part for her relationship to the elder McMichael, a former police officer who worked in the Brunswick DA’s office until 2019. Greg McMichael called Johnson from the scene of the shooting and left a voice mail seeking advice: “Could you call me as soon as you possibly can?” he said, according to a recording submitted in court.
Greg McMichael’s phone log for that day did not show a call back from Johnson.
Three days after Arbery’s shooting, Johnson reached out to the state attorney general’s office asking that someone be assigned to advise the police, according to a letter provided by Carr’s office. But Johnson’s office had already brought in Waycross District Attorney George Barnhill to advise police starting the day after Arbery’s death — inappropriately inserting herself into the case, critics said.
Within a day of Arbery’s death, Barnhill had reviewed the evidence, met with police and told them he saw no reason to arrest any of the three men involved.
By April, under pressure from Arbery’s mother, Barnhill wrote that he believed it best to step aside, but still defended the suspects, saying Georgia law protected their right to perform a “citizen’s arrest” and then use deadly force in self-defense after Arbery “initiated the fight.”
Neither Johnson nor Barnhill initially told the attorney general that Barnhill had already stepped in, Carr’s office says, or that Barnhill might have conflicts of his own, because Barnhill’s son worked for Johnson. The attorney general appointed Barnhill.