• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Merged Gaza just launched an unprovoked attack on Israel

To denote when two or more threads have been merged

How does one terrorist act mean it's okay to attack Gaza as Israel is doing? It reminds me in a way of how Bush started stupid, mindless wars due to one terrorist attack on the US.
I seem to remember that FDR committed the US to war against Japan based upon a single terror attack.
How to say, don't take anything I ever say seriously, without saying 'don't take anything I ever say seriously'. The parallels between Pearl Harbor and 10/7 are near non-existent, other than there was an attacker and an attacked. Scope, goals, targets, history. Jesus Fucking Christ what a stupid thing to say.

And the entire strawman of 'Israel isn't allowed to defend itself then?!' is just as stupid. The issue wasn't self defense, it was the extensive duration, widespread nature, and seemingly inhumane take on it... and how it wasn't getting the hostages home.
 
Israel has always promoter peace? Somebody has been drinking the Israeli Kool Aide.

Long running Netayahu hs always been anti peace well before taking office.

Several peqce accords were trashed by Israel. They don't want it. They'd have to give up colonization. If Palestinians get any kind of formal recognition they have stanging to make claims against Israel.

Netanyahu said explicitly what was once Israel was given by god to Jews and they can do whatever they see fit with it. He is the Jewish equivalent of our biblical literalist Christians.

Yigal Amir
In November 1995, he was assassinated by Yigal Amir, an extremist who opposed the terms of the Oslo Accords. Amir was convicted of Rabin's murder and sentenced to life imprisonment.

There is evidence Netanyahu knew of the plot and did nothing.

And again modern Israel formed itself by taking land from Arabs. They are doing it as we speak.
 
Nevermind the total lack of effort and sheer indifference of Netanyahu's regime in retrieving the hostages taken on Oct 7 three fucking years ago. That they prioritise genocide, collective punishment and other fun war crimes over that is telling in and of itself.

That's quite a ridiculous assessment. How do you propose that hostages were to be freed without taking the war to Hamas? And note that direct hostage rescue was done in one instance where four hostages were held in two ostensibly civilian apartments. By the way, one of these apartments was owned and occupied by a Hamas father-son duo who had physician and journalist as day jobs.

That brings me to civilian casualties. They are to some extent inevitable in urban warfare, but there are more civilian casualties because of Hamas (and its allies) operating from among civilians. To accuse Israel of "genocide" over casualties that Hamas' strategy and tactics have caused is to swallow Hamas' propaganda like a good useful idiot (not an insult, but an actual term of art).
 
Several peqce accords were trashed by Israel. They don't want it.
Bullshit. Israel successfully made peace deals with Egypt and Jordan. And Israel offered Palestinians a very generous peace accord at Camp David. Palestinians refused, and instead started the 2nd Intifada which involved many suicide bombings such as this one or this one.
It is true that Bibi is more hardline than the likes of Ehud Barak, but his return to prime ministership in 2009 is a direct consequence of the failure of negotiating with Palestinians.
They'd have to give up colonization.
What do you mean by "colonization"? In reality it is the Arabs that colonized the Land of Israel.
If Palestinians get any kind of formal recognition they have stanging to make claims against Israel.
What about being held responsible for their crimes against humanity, including against their own people. For just one recent example, it is a war crime to use a hospital for militant operations.
Netanyahu said explicitly what was once Israel was given by god to Jews and they can do whatever they see fit with it. He is the Jewish equivalent of our biblical literalist Christians.
[citation needed]
There is evidence Netanyahu knew of the plot and did nothing.
[citation needed]
How would Netanyahu have known of the plot, or be able to act to thwart it? He wasn't even in government at the time.
And again modern Israel formed itself by taking land from Arabs. They are doing it as we speak.
Wrong. That land was occupied by Ottomans before becoming a British protectorate after WWI. Why do you think Arab colonizers have some sort of claim on the Land of Israel? They do not even have a native name for the land, which is why they use a Greco-Roman colonial name which has a sound that does not even exist in their language. And to preclude a possible objection, Palestinian Arabs have nothing whatsoever to do with the ancient Philistines, which are descendants of the Sea Peoples.
 
“It’s a war,” she shouted. “You have seen both societies! You cannot tell me with a straight face that you see us as being the same as them! All you have seen are the horrible things they do and the horrible things they make us do.”
— Jason Pargin, There are NO Giant Crabs in this Novel
 
No need, your post does not address my Israel’s caring about Gazans.
The Israelis have done more to promote peace and prosperity for Palestinians, especially Gazans, than the Palestinians leadership has done for generations!
That's why the violent Islamists have been starting wars against Israel all these decades.
Tom
So violent Islamists have been starting violent wars against Israel because of Israel’s success in promoting peace and prosperity in the West Bank and Gaza?
Yep
That's why the Gazans keep attacking Israel.
Tom
And you know this because…..?
 
How to say, don't take anything I ever say seriously, without saying 'don't take anything I ever say seriously'. The parallels between Pearl Harbor and 10/7 are near non-existent, other than there was an attacker and an attacked. Scope, goals, targets, history. Jesus Fucking Christ what a stupid thing to say.
There are similarities, but also differences. If anything, 10/7 was worse because Japanese did not massacre and kidnap civilians.
And the entire strawman of 'Israel isn't allowed to defend itself then?!' is just as stupid.
It's not a strawman though. Protesters demanding "ceasefire now" literally the day after these attacks shows that they do not think Israel should be able to defend themselves against Palestinian attacks, no matter how brutal.
The issue wasn't self defense, it was the extensive duration,
Two years between the 2023 attacks and the 2025 is not that extensive in duration, and is in fact much shorter than similar US operations, e.g. in Afghanistan.
widespread nature,
Hamas and its allies had a widespread presence in Gaza, which necessitated a widespread response. You attack where the enemy is.
and seemingly inhumane take on it..
In reality it is the Hamas tactics that made this war more inhumane than it needed to be.
and how it wasn't getting the hostages home.
But it did. What would be the alternative? Hamas thought - because of the lopsided exchange rate in the Shalit deal among other things - that hundreds of hostages they took would guarantee them release of all Palestinian terrorists. Without this war, that would be the price they would not have budged from. Furthermore, the ~1200 dead Israelis would also remain unavenged and Hamas would have emerged stronger, both because this victory would be a major propaganda coup but also because they would have increased their ranks by thousands of experienced terrorists.
Instead, many thousands of Hamas leaders and fighters have been killed or maimed, most of their hardware as well as most of their tunnel network has been destroyed, and Israel - while still having to release many terror prisoners - released far fewer than they would have had to without this war.

The proposal of freeing the hostages without taking the war to Hamas and their allies is just not tenable nor feasible. And, remember, this is a war that Hamas and its Gaza allies started. Israel is just faulted for not immediately capitulating, which is insane.
 
No need, your post does not address my Israel’s caring about Gazans.
The Israelis have done more to promote peace and prosperity for Palestinians, especially Gazans, than the Palestinians leadership has done for generations!
That's why the violent Islamists have been starting wars against Israel all these decades.
Tom
So violent Islamists have been starting violent wars against Israel because of Israel’s success in promoting peace and prosperity in the West Bank and Gaza?
No. Because “kill the infidel” is a fundamental tenet of their religious belief.
 
No need, your post does not address my Israel’s caring about Gazans.
The Israelis have done more to promote peace and prosperity for Palestinians, especially Gazans, than the Palestinians leadership has done for generations!
That's why the violent Islamists have been starting wars against Israel all these decades.
Tom
So violent Islamists have been starting violent wars against Israel because of Israel’s success in promoting peace and prosperity in the West Bank and Gaza?
No. Because “kill the infidel” is a fundamental tenet of their religious belief.
Tell that to TomC, not me.
 

I don't think its always antisemitism. But often when pro-Palestine supporters try arguing their case there's no arguments. There's zero attempt to understand the actions of Israel. Then its antisemitism. That's all that's left.

But most often I think its antisemetic propaganda that gets spread and passed around. When it reaches someone otherwise sensible, they might be convinced by the argument. That is still antisemitism. We would never condone anyome committing an act of hate crime, just because they didn't know any better in any other context.

There's now more antisemetic propaganda floating about, on every channel, than ever before. Failure to do due diligence and think critically about it at this time, I think is inexcusable.

I niether tolerate antisemitism due to ignorance or maliciousness. Because the result is the same.

And this is perhaps the most important. Israel controlling Gaza, is at the moment, probably, the Gazan peoples best and only chance to be ruled by a power that cares about them, and offer stability, wise and non-corrupt govornence. So being pro Israel right now is also being pro Palestine. And being pro-Palestine right now, is in practice being pro-Hamas, which will only lead to endless carnage.

If you care about Palestinian civilians the best option is to support Israel
View attachment 55860
Because religious zealots who engage in terrorist actions have proven themselves to be fair governors of their people and support democracy and liberty?
The irony is that aptly describes the ultra-orthodox right in Israel.
Emily Lake said:
Do you actually think that Hamas is going to become a bastion of freedom and sustainability if they succeed in genociding the entire Israeli population? Or do you think that palestinians are going to somehow force democracy into place and vote hamas out, and hamas will meekly concede to the wishes of the people?

Because my money is on them ruling like afghanistan and iran.
You missed the point. It is either delusional or mendacious to claim the gov’t of Israel cares about Gazans or that it will oversee Gaza with wisdom as Dr Z claims.

No one is suggesting Gazans will become paragons of democracy or that they will obliterate Israel. Those are straw men.
In all of the Middle-East the Palestinians living inside Israel are the least oppressed and most free Palestinians. That includes oppression by other Palestinians. The Palestinians living inside Israel are among the most free people and least oppressed in all of the Middle-East.

Tell me more about how I'm deluded?
The slaves who were referred to as house n*****s in the Antebellum South of the United States were the least oppressed and most free of all the black people in Mississippi.

That does not mean their human rights were generally respected.

Heck, it doesn't even mean their humanity was generally accepted.

Also, you are deluded in thinking Palestinians found no refuge anywhere in the region outside of Israel. But even if you were right, you are even more deluded in thinking your assertion is somehow an argument against the Right of Palestinians to return to their former homes. If anything, it strengthens the argument that they should be allowed back since they will be less oppressed there. And it mirrors the Zionist claim that Jews have a Right of Return to the land around Jerusalem due to all the oppression they suffer outside of it.
 
Last edited:
Several peqce accords were trashed by Israel. They don't want it.
Bullshit. Israel successfully made peace deals with Egypt and Jordan. And Israel offered Palestinians a very generous peace accord at Camp David.
Tell us more about this generous offer.

What specifically was offered? What borders were proposed? What resources would be shared, what would be exclusively Palestinian, who would be in charge of the sacred sites, and how would compliance be monitored and policed?

I can link to the Oslo Accords so you can read the details. Link to this proposal you keep talking about so we can all see how "generous" it was in comparison.

Also, please stop lying about the Camp David negotiations.
 

I don't think its always antisemitism. But often when pro-Palestine supporters try arguing their case there's no arguments. There's zero attempt to understand the actions of Israel. Then its antisemitism. That's all that's left.

But most often I think its antisemetic propaganda that gets spread and passed around. When it reaches someone otherwise sensible, they might be convinced by the argument. That is still antisemitism. We would never condone anyome committing an act of hate crime, just because they didn't know any better in any other context.

There's now more antisemetic propaganda floating about, on every channel, than ever before. Failure to do due diligence and think critically about it at this time, I think is inexcusable.

I niether tolerate antisemitism due to ignorance or maliciousness. Because the result is the same.

And this is perhaps the most important. Israel controlling Gaza, is at the moment, probably, the Gazan peoples best and only chance to be ruled by a power that cares about them, and offer stability, wise and non-corrupt govornence. So being pro Israel right now is also being pro Palestine. And being pro-Palestine right now, is in practice being pro-Hamas, which will only lead to endless carnage.

If you care about Palestinian civilians the best option is to support Israel
View attachment 55860
Because religious zealots who engage in terrorist actions have proven themselves to be fair governors of their people and support democracy and liberty?
The irony is that aptly describes the ultra-orthodox right in Israel.
Emily Lake said:
Do you actually think that Hamas is going to become a bastion of freedom and sustainability if they succeed in genociding the entire Israeli population? Or do you think that palestinians are going to somehow force democracy into place and vote hamas out, and hamas will meekly concede to the wishes of the people?

Because my money is on them ruling like afghanistan and iran.
You missed the point. It is either delusional or mendacious to claim the gov’t of Israel cares about Gazans or that it will oversee Gaza with wisdom as Dr Z claims.

No one is suggesting Gazans will become paragons of democracy or that they will obliterate Israel. Those are straw men.
In all of the Middle-East the Palestinians living inside Israel are the least oppressed and most free Palestinians. That includes oppression by other Palestinians. The Palestinians living inside Israel are among the most free people and least oppressed in all of the Middle-East.

Tell me more about how I'm deluded?
No need, your post does not address my Israel’s caring about Gazans.

1) your worries anout the future is paranoia. Nobody knows.

2) Gazan's couldn't possibly have been more opressed than under Hamas. Corruption is also a form of opression. Israel has low corruption.

This is like the UK complaining that Hong Kong isn't democratic under China, forgetting that it was never democratic under the British.
 
Israel has gotten a lot of mislage out of plaything the victim.

Look at the tear jerking commercials asking for money for old survivors of the Holocaust and old Jews a who are allegedly starving elsewhere.

While Trump makes a big show of it, our relations with the Mid East and Egypt have always been transactional. We give aid and they use part of it to buy US weapons and U*S goods.

About $1.62 billion in aid was obligated for fiscal year (FY) 2025, the most recent fully-reported year with net positive obligations for this country. Another $1.16 billion has been reported for FY 2026.

We say Jordan is an ally, it is more a client state.

When Jordan and Egypt made peace with Israel you can bet US money was behind it.

Egy7pt's Sadat and Israel's Rabin were assassinated by their own people for supporting peace.

The apologists need to stop looking at Israel as Jewish and look at the reality of Israel's actions and internal politics and culture aka Zionism.

Back in the 90s I saw a shift starting in American Christians. A shift from antisemitism to Israel being part of the end times prophies.

A large part of it was a long running Israelii propaganda program. Tours of the Holy Land for Christians. Tours for American politicians. The 'Jerusalem Syndrome', Christians visiting Israel hear voices and have hallucinates.

Israeli paid vacations for American politicians. Biden refereed to Netanyahu as Bibi, his nickname.

Israel spends a lot of money every year on influencing politics and Christians.

AIPAC (the American Israel Public Affairs Committee) is a long-established U.S. lobbying organization that advocates pro‑Israel policy to Congress and the executive branch and has deployed significant political spending in recent election cycles to support or oppose candidates based on their stances toward Israel [1] [2]. Its rising electoral aggression in 2024—through vehicles like AIPAC PAC and the United Democracy Project—triggered a broad backlash from progressive groups and some prominent Jewish Americans who accuse it of trying to punish lawmakers calling for a Gaza ceasefire


The image many have of Israel is a crafted political image. Israel successfully created the image in America that all Palestinians are terrorists.
 
Z

I remember you saying you are a fan of Aleister Crowley. A self styled mystic.

I am wondering if you are enamored with the popular mystical image of ancient Jews. Many Christians are. Does the thought of Jews give a warm fuzzy feeling?

I knew an Evangelical who believed ancient Jews inverted math, science, language, and writing.

Indiana Jones And The Lost Ark?
 
Israel has gotten a lot of mislage out of plaything the victim.

More than the Palestinians? Really?
Pop quiz, multiple choice.

Jews in Palestine created modern Israel by:

1. God giving the land to hem.
2. It was given to them by the Brits.
3. They took land by force displacing Arabs.
4. I haven't got a clue.
5. I know the answer but I will not acknowledge it.
 

I don't think its always antisemitism. But often when pro-Palestine supporters try arguing their case there's no arguments. There's zero attempt to understand the actions of Israel. Then its antisemitism. That's all that's left.

But most often I think its antisemetic propaganda that gets spread and passed around. When it reaches someone otherwise sensible, they might be convinced by the argument. That is still antisemitism. We would never condone anyome committing an act of hate crime, just because they didn't know any better in any other context.

There's now more antisemetic propaganda floating about, on every channel, than ever before. Failure to do due diligence and think critically about it at this time, I think is inexcusable.

I niether tolerate antisemitism due to ignorance or maliciousness. Because the result is the same.

And this is perhaps the most important. Israel controlling Gaza, is at the moment, probably, the Gazan peoples best and only chance to be ruled by a power that cares about them, and offer stability, wise and non-corrupt govornence. So being pro Israel right now is also being pro Palestine. And being pro-Palestine right now, is in practice being pro-Hamas, which will only lead to endless carnage.

If you care about Palestinian civilians the best option is to support Israel
View attachment 55860
Because religious zealots who engage in terrorist actions have proven themselves to be fair governors of their people and support democracy and liberty?
The irony is that aptly describes the ultra-orthodox right in Israel.
Emily Lake said:
Do you actually think that Hamas is going to become a bastion of freedom and sustainability if they succeed in genociding the entire Israeli population? Or do you think that palestinians are going to somehow force democracy into place and vote hamas out, and hamas will meekly concede to the wishes of the people?

Because my money is on them ruling like afghanistan and iran.
You missed the point. It is either delusional or mendacious to claim the gov’t of Israel cares about Gazans or that it will oversee Gaza with wisdom as Dr Z claims.

No one is suggesting Gazans will become paragons of democracy or that they will obliterate Israel. Those are straw men.
In all of the Middle-East the Palestinians living inside Israel are the least oppressed and most free Palestinians. That includes oppression by other Palestinians. The Palestinians living inside Israel are among the most free people and least oppressed in all of the Middle-East.

Tell me more about how I'm deluded?
No need, your post does not address my Israel’s caring about Gazans.

1) your worries anout the future is paranoia. Nobody knows.
I didn’t mention the future.
DrZoidberg said:
2) Gazan's couldn't possibly have been more opressed than under Hamas. Corruption is also a form of opression. Israel has low corruption.
Of course oppression can always be worse.
DrZoidberg said:
This is like the UK complaining that Hong Kong isn't democratic under China, forgetting that it was never democratic under the British.
You’re babbling response enforces my observation.
 
Pop quiz, multiple choice.

Jews in Palestine created modern Israel by:

1. God giving the land to hem.
2. It was given to them by the Brits.
3. They took land by force displacing Arabs.
4. I haven't got a clue.
5. I know the answer but I will not acknowledge it.
None of the above.
Tom
 
Back
Top Bottom