• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Merged Gaza just launched an unprovoked attack on Israel

To denote when two or more threads have been merged
The Voice of History

Hitler Buys a Bunch of Land From Germany’s Neighbors, and Then Becomes All Pissy When They Try to Take the Land Back

IIDB.org (Internet News Service) — In the late 1930s to the early 1940s, Adolf Hitler, the leader of Nazi Germany, bought a whole bunch of land from Poland, Denmark, Norway, northern France, the Balkans, North Africa, and much of European Russia, and then got all pissy when his sellers decided they wanted the land back.

“Fuck them!” Hitler cried, angrily throwing a pencil against a map of the bought territory while his aides looked on in terror. “I paid billions for that land and it’s mine, mine, mine!”

The sales receipts included Hitler’s right to murder Jews.
 
Jewish land purchase in Palestine

In the 1880s, Jews, began purchasing land and properties across Ottoman Palestine in order to expand the collective territorial ownership of the Yishuv. Large Jewish corporations and private Jewish buyers led this effort through multiple intermittent transactions that continued after Mandatory Palestine was established in 1918. The largest of these arrangements, known as the Sursock Purchases, resulted in the procurement of the Jezreel Valley and the Bay of Haifa by the 1930s.

The purchase of land was often accompanied by the eviction of the Arab tenants.[2] On 1 April 1945, the British administration's statistics showed that Jewish buyers had legal ownership over approximately 5.67% of the Mandate's total land area, while state domain (a large part of which was held in hereditary lease or had undetermined ownership) was 46%.[3] By the end of 1947, Jewish ownership had increased to 6.6%.[4] This cycle of land acquisition ultimately ended when the Israeli Declaration of Independence yielded the founding of the Jewish state on 14 May 1948.

Jews legally owned a bit less than 7% of Mandatory Palestine when the State of Israel was declared to exist on more than half of it.

The new government (aka The Jewish Agency for Palestine) then declared that the land belonging to dead or fled Palestinians was property of the State of Israel. Under the supervision of Yosef Weitz, homes and communities were razed to prevent the return of refugees while the ownership of other buildings and properties was transferred to Jewish immigrants.

No compensation has ever been offered to those whose homes and properties were stolen or destroyed.

So, no, Jews in Palestine did not create modern Israel by buying the land and then defending it.
 
Last edited:
Israel has gotten a lot of mislage out of plaything the victim.

More than the Palestinians? Really?
You just said this a few posts ago "Gazan's[sic] couldn't possibly have been more opressed[sic] than under Hamas."

BTW, that's a completely ridiculous statement. I don't remember Hamas ever doing this to Palestinians.

View attachment 55879
Hamas did that to Palestinians by attacking a neighboring country and then throwing Gazans under the bomb.
Tom
"Baby, look what you made me do".

Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.

Fuck, but with Tom's logic, what Hamas did was perfectly justified because the places they attacked on October 7 were illegal settlements anyways and Israel threw those settlers under the bus. See how fucked up that sort of reasoning is?
 
Last edited:
Jewish land purchase in Palestine

In the 1880s, Jews, began purchasing land and properties across Ottoman Palestine in order to expand the collective territorial ownership of the Yishuv. Large Jewish corporations and private Jewish buyers led this effort through multiple intermittent transactions that continued after Mandatory Palestine was established in 1918. The largest of these arrangements, known as the Sursock Purchases, resulted in the procurement of the Jezreel Valley and the Bay of Haifa by the 1930s.

The purchase of land was often accompanied by the eviction of the Arab tenants.[2] On 1 April 1945, the British administration's statistics showed that Jewish buyers had legal ownership over approximately 5.67% of the Mandate's total land area, while state domain (a large part of which was held in hereditary lease or had undetermined ownership) was 46%.[3] By the end of 1947, Jewish ownership had increased to 6.6%.[4] This cycle of land acquisition ultimately ended when the Israeli Declaration of Independence yielded the founding of the Jewish state on 14 May 1948.

Jews legally owned a bit less than 7% of Mandatory Palestine when the State of Israel was declared to exist on more than half of it.

The new government (aka The Jewish Agency for Palestine) then declared that the land belonging to dead or fled Palestinians was property of the State of Israel. Under the supervision of Yosef Weitz, homes and communities were razed to prevent the return of refugees while the ownership of other buildings and properties were transferred to Jewish immigrants.

No compensation has ever been offered to those whose homes and properties were stolen or destroyed.
Deir Yassin is the best recruitment ad Hamas could ever want.
 
Pop quiz, multiple choice.

Jews in Palestine created modern Israel by:

1. God giving the land to hem.
2. It was given to them by the Brits.
3. They took land by force displacing Arabs.
4. I haven't got a clue.
5. I know the answer but I will not acknowledge it.
None of the above.
Tom
Then how?
Bought it.
Defended it.
Refused to let violent enemies move in.
Tom
Oversimplification vs. oversimplification. A lot of it was bought, and a lot of it was taken by force displacing Arabs, and a lot of it was taken by force without displacing Arabs, and a lot of it was taken by force and Arabs left but whether they were displaced or they left because Arab leadership urged them to leave is disputed. (Moreover, a lot of the land that was bought was bought from absentee landlords, and usually the Arab tenants' leases weren't renewed, so they too were displaced.) I haven't seen any evidence that any of the land was given to the Jews by God and/or the Brits.

Bought it?
Correct.
The huge bulk of the territory that the UN recognized in 1948 was bought from the legal owners.
Tom
The huge bulk of the territory that the UN recognized in 1948 was the Negev desert. It had no legal owners and Israelis didn't buy it, just occupied it -- its last legal owner was the Ottoman Empire government, which stopped existing in 1922. A lot of the land outside the Negev had the same status. If you mean the arable, occupied, and owned land, how much was bought from the legal owners is disputed but estimates I've seen put it below 50%.
 
Last edited:
Yes they were buying land, and the Brits udder the Mandate limited it.

Under the British Mandate the Jews pushed to move Arabsout of an area to make a s space for Jews.

When Jews declared an independent state they got prime agricultural and industrial land and property they could not have afforded to buy.

Arabs not inside the boundary of the new state were denied return to their property.

Today Jews immigrate to Israel to get 'free' land in the West Bank.

In the occupied West Bank Israel condemns Arab property, bulldozes it, and gives construction permits to Jews. Its been goingg on for decades. Slow motion ethnic cleansing,

And now it is blatant. Jewish settlers attacking Palestinians and forcing them off their property.

When Palestinians fight back they are terrorists.

Under the Brits the Jews had undergrad weapons and ammunition factories. They rersorted to bombings. To te Brits tey were terrorists.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Honesty requires that Hama has been around for almost 40 years with control of Gaza for 20 years. And recognizing Gazan civilian casualties are magnitudes larger than Israeli casualties (military and civilian). From https://jewishvirtuallibrary.org/comprehensive-listing-of-terrorism-victims-in-israel, there have been almost 4,000 Israeli civilian (this includes the Gazan war) killed by Palestinian terrorists since 1993. Compare that with the deaths of an estimated 40,000 to 60,000 Gazan civilians.
 
Last edited:
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
...so picking a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road was totally justified. Got it.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
Indeed. It's been tit-for-tat for a very long time. The difference now is that Bibi decided to be a FAR bigger tit than the tat justified.
 
The conflicts are deadly serious. That being said there is a comical aspect to it,they are all beating each other over the head. Utterly dysfunctional.

A farce like the Three Stooges or Marx Brothers would do. Too bad there is nobody around who would dare to portray the Mid East. Silly ass ponp08s leaders at war with each other.

The region has no lack of physical and intellectual resources. It should be thriivng.


Duck Soup is a 1933 American pre-Code musical comedy film written by Bert Kalmar and Harry Ruby (with additional dialogue by Arthur Sheekman and Nat Perrin) and directed by Leo McCarey. Released by Paramount Pictures on November 17, 1933, it stars the four Marx Brothers (Groucho, Harpo, Chico, and Zeppo) and also features Margaret Dumont, Louis Calhern, Raquel Torres and Edgar Kennedy.

Plot
Wealthy widow Gloria Teasdale is asked to give twenty million dollars to the small, financially struggling nation of Freedonia; she agrees on the condition that Rufus T. Firefly is appointed the country's leader. Meanwhile, Ambassador Trentino of neighboring Sylvania is scheming to provoke a revolution in Freedonia in order to annex it. He sends two spies, Chicolini and Pinky, to Freedonia to find out information about Firefly. To his disappointment, Chicolini and Pinky end up spying on the wrong man, but he agrees to give them another chance.



You Nazty Spy! is a 1940 comedy film directed by Jules White and starring American slapstick comedy team The Three Stooges (Moe Howard, Larry Fine, and Curly Howard). It is the 44th short film released by Columbia Pictures starring the comedians, who released 190 short films for the studio between 1934 and 1959.

Plot
Three munitions manufacturers, discontent with reduced profits due to King Herman the 6+7⁄8's pacifist policies, conspire to overthrow him and institute a dictatorship by finding somebody stupid enough to be a figurehead leader. The trio selects the unwitting Stooges, working as wallpaper hangers, as figureheads for their regime. Moe Hailstone assumes the role of the leader, directly spoofing Adolf Hitler; Curly Gallstone becomes Field Marshall and is a composite of Benito Mussolini and Hermann Göring; and Larry Pebble becomes Minister of Propaganda, spoofing Joseph Goebbels, respectively.
The Mid East and Ukraine is SOS, same old shit.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take. Nobody is proposing a way to stop the ruler-du-jour in Gaza from attacking Israel. It ends up feeling like the version of "sanity" being proposed is that Israel should just keep on letting themselves be attacked and harmed.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take. Nobody is proposing a way to stop the ruler-du-jour in Gaza from attacking Israel. It ends up feeling like the version of "sanity" being proposed is that Israel should just keep on letting themselves be attacked and harmed.
What is your take on the Oslo Accords and Netanyahu's role in their being abandoned by Israel? And what is your view on the settlements Israel keeps building outside its borders and filling with its citizens that it then sends its soldiers to defend?
 
...so picking a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road was totally justified. Got it.
You are completely ignoring the fact that Hezbollah joined with Hamas in attacking Israel in the aftermath of 10/7.

But I guess you think Jews should also meekly accept rockets being shot at them from Lebanon and not retaliate in any way whatsoever.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take.
The 2nd sentence ironically proves your first point.

BTW, Israel has not proposed an effective way from keeping attacks from Gaza.
 
Back
Top Bottom