The Star Wars Trilogy (VII to IX) made over $4 billion and is approaching $5 billion. On a budget less than 1/5 that, I'm pretty certain Disney will consider that a wild success.
What I found odd was a couple people I know had liked the newest two movies, but then after the final, they soured on the entire trilogy.
I would probably fit into that category. I found the first two movies in the trilogy passable, with the second being the better movie of the two. After the final episode, I think the entire trilogy was a waste, though I still think
The Last Jedi was the best of the three. So, my problem is mostly with JJ Abrams, and here is why:
When
The Force Awakens came out I was excited. We were getting a new Star Wars film that continued the original trilogy, and we could forget about the prequel trilogy, because they had learned from that mistake. To some degree they had, the tone was different, and they approached it from the angle of trying to the same things that made the original trilogy great. Unfortunately, it was still executed poorly plot wise. It was a rehash of
A New Hope, with a McGuffin hunt running through the entire thing. Most fans were not thrilled with either the rehash, or the McGuffin hunt, they were what we complained about the most.
The Last Jedi then went off and did it's own thing, remaining barely connected to the events that happened in the previous movie. It had gotten a little better, and I had hopes that the final movie would right the ship. But when I got to the theater I was presented with a fucking rehash of
Return of the Jedi with a fucking McGuffin hunt running through the entire thing. In both cases the McGuffin hunt was entirely unnecessary. The McGuffin hunt in
The Last Jedi was bad enough, but at least it did not introduce major plot holes. The
Rise of Skywalker McGuffin hunt did just that.
Spoiler:
Our heroes needed a key to find the planet where the Emperor set up his new base of operations. There were only two keys made, Kylo Ren found the first one and used it to get there himself. Yet, when our heroes finally arrive, there is a massive fleet of Star Destroyers there that would have taken millions, if not billions, of people to construct and crew. How did they get there? Why didn't they need a key? The keys were freaking old, as old as Rey, and had been apparently lost for some time, yet some of the First Order officers that we met in the previous movies were even there, with no key necessary for them. At least in The Force Awakens there was no indication that anyone else had been able to locate Luke without having to find the McGuffin, not so in this case. That is a plot hole of a size that you can fly a fleet of Star Destroyers through, and sadly it was not the only plot hole in the movie.
The Simpsons captured the issue when media analysts were trying to figure out what kids wanted for a cartoon show.
[YOUTUBE]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oqk_fN0NRgg[/YOUTUBE]
Star Wars suffers the same problem.
It's not like they didn't have years to hear about the problems fans had with
The Force Awakens, and make sure they did not repeat those mistakes. It seems much more like Abrams said, "Oh so you didn't like the stupid shit I did in
The Force Awakens, well strap yourselves in, because I am dialing that shit up to 11 this time around."
And that is why my answer to this trilogy is a simple "Fuck you, JJ Abrams."