The Mockingjay Part 1 (Hunger Games 3)
8/10
Grim and disturbing. Tonally different from the other 2 movies.
You move the movie Gladiator from the pomp and spectacle of the Coliseum into the gritty world of those rebelling against it.
That's what this movie is.
This movie veers more toward the adult side of the conflict. Some movie critics lament that Katniss is more passive in this movie, but they seem to forget that Katniss is only 17 years old and is still suffering from PTSD.
She has been thrust from a world where she is forced to plan and take action, into a new world where adults are actually doing the fighting instead of kids.
So of course she's going to appear more passive by comparison. The movie is uncomfortable because even though Katniss is the Mockingjay by her own actions, you see
that she is being used again. Earlier by the Capital and now by the Rebels as propaganda fodder and Katniss is forced to cooperate again, to defend and save her friends' lives. Even her little sister is starting to learn how to work the system.
The movie earlier intersperses Katniss' actions and words with events in the districts but the latter half of the movie drops this as events focus
more on the events in District 13.
There is never any real explanation as to why
District 13 survived. They pass off a weak explanation as "we were military and this is how we survive", but the Capital, as we've seen from earlier movies, is well funded and not afraid to send in men with guns. So why would they only attack from the air and never follow up with ground troops to root them out? I think there was a hint of fear about nukes, so possibly that's why the Capital doesn't push? Not sure.
Some things don't make sense, like why would a noob like Gale
would be sent in on an obviously special forces type mission when his only experience is firing a bow. Yes, he volunteered, but he can be turned down.
I do like that the whole movie has you questioning who is still playing games with one another. Whether it's on a personal level as Katniss looks at
Peeta in the propaganda movies from the Capital she marvels that "He's still playing the game"...or President Coin with President Snow or Plutarch with Snow.
You wonder who can really be trusted.
I do like that Katniss, with help from
Finnick finally realize that she did love Peeta after all. All her focus is on him and she is agonized by what is being done to him and continues to champion him, even against the Rebels. This is upsetting to Gale whose jealously finally emerges - not to his credit.
Dark and troubling with some very adult and gruesome scenes, and only some occasions for levity, this is a grownups movie.
Recommend.