Toni
Contributor
- Joined
- Aug 10, 2011
- Messages
- 21,112
- Basic Beliefs
- Peace on Earth, goodwill towards all
No, it does NOT.And even if it doesn't drain budgets it lowers the average student ability and thus the education that students will get. This is inevitable as a teacher can't teach at different levels to different students in the same class. You either don't challenge the best ones or you leave the worst ones behind. This is a big force behind white flight and it's a big force in why private schools can outperform public ones. (Everything else being equal a selective admissions policy will improve education.)Immigration is a good thing and a bad thing. From my personal knowledge, increasing the non-English speaking population at schools drains schools budgets. It just does. People who have lived here for years or generations can be very upset about resources being taken from their kids and used for someone else’s kids. This is true whenever school budgets get tight and programming and staffing gets cut—regardless of the reasons. Raising property taxes ( a major source of public school funding in the US) is also
You seem to be equating English proficiency with learning ability. Given that your wife is not a native English speaker, I would think you would know better.
A classroom with students of different backgrounds and abilities and different t cultures is a golden opportunity to learn MORE, not less.
Yes students may need extra help with English proficiency just as some students need extra help with math or science or art or music. That’s why schools exist.
Schools have special programs to help non-native English speaking students gain the proficiency they need. But those cost money. Not a problem for well endowed schoolboy many struggle to provide education and programming with thought the extra cost of ESL teachers.