• Welcome to the Internet Infidels Discussion Board.

Merged Gaza just launched an unprovoked attack on Israel

To denote when two or more threads have been merged
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take. Nobody is proposing a way to stop the ruler-du-jour in Gaza from attacking Israel. It ends up feeling like the version of "sanity" being proposed is that Israel should just keep on letting themselves be attacked and harmed.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take. Nobody is proposing a way to stop the ruler-du-jour in Gaza from attacking Israel. It ends up feeling like the version of "sanity" being proposed is that Israel should just keep on letting themselves be attacked and harmed.
What is your take on the Oslo Accords and Netanyahu's role in their being abandoned by Israel? And what is your view on the settlements Israel keeps building outside its borders and filling with its citizens that it then sends its soldiers to defend?
 
...so picking a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road was totally justified. Got it.
You are completely ignoring the fact that Hezbollah joined with Hamas in attacking Israel in the aftermath of 10/7.

But I guess you think Jews should also meekly accept rockets being shot at them from Lebanon and not retaliate in any way whatsoever.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take.
The 2nd sentence ironically proves your first point.

BTW, Israel has not proposed an effective way from keeping attacks from Gaza.
 
Why is an Israel apologist complaining about a lack of condemnations against Israel?
This is exactly my point. You and your Ilk condemn Israel when it's your friends from Hamas who are committing war crimes by operating from hospitals.
You wrote “you won’t hear any condemnation of it”, which means me and my ilk aren’t condemning Israel. You are contradicting yourself.
 
You wrote “you won’t hear any condemnation of it”, which means me and my ilk aren’t condemning Israel. You are contradicting yourself.
I am not contradicting myself. You are just purposely misunderstanding my point.

Now do you have anything to contribute to the issue of Hamas operating from the Nasser Hospital?
 
You wrote “you won’t hear any condemnation of it”which means me and my ilk aren’t condemning Israel. You are contradicting yourself.
I am not contradicting myself. You are just purposely misunderstanding my point.
You have yet to show how my interpretation is wrong. The bold- faced quote means no condemnation to the functionally literate .
Derec said:
Now do you have anything to contribute to the issue of Hamas operating from the Nasser Hospital?
Yes.
 
Anyone who still thinks Israel's reaction to October 7 was appropriate and proportionate is a fucking sociopath. You punching my Mum doesn't give me justification to kill your entire family, burn your fucking house down, then pick a fight with the Lebanese neighbours up the road.
That's an interesting way to frame it, I suppose.

I mean, let's be at least a little more honest about it here - they have been systematically punching your mom, raping your sister, and shooting your brother for on the order of 50 years. And on Oct 7, they kidnapped and tortured your mom, sister, brother, and kids and tried to set your house on fire.
Way to take a point and then respond to something that wasn't as important. People just have to get their fucking analogies in.

Israel and the Middle East have trading killing for a long time now, with Israel generally being the party needing to respond against first aggression. Israel's response to the 10/7 massacre was too long, too destructive, and most importantly, relatively ineffective. Hamas still exists. Worst yet, Palestine has a generation of people that only know Netanyahu rule. So things are not going to get better.

I wish sanity would take over, but no one in the theater in power wants the other side to know peace and there are way too many on either side that would be glad to see to that. And the Israel/US attack on Iran likely made it even worse.
I don't know what you think sanity ought to be. Israel was too mean to the people who have repeatedly attacked them for half a century, on a regular basis seems to be the take. Nobody is proposing a way to stop the ruler-du-jour in Gaza from attacking Israel. It ends up feeling like the version of "sanity" being proposed is that Israel should just keep on letting themselves be attacked and harmed.
What is your take on the Oslo Accords and Netanyahu's role in their being abandoned by Israel? And what is your view on the settlements Israel keeps building outside its borders and filling with its citizens that it then sends its soldiers to defend?
Israel needs to stop the settlements.
 
You have yet to show how my interpretation is wrong. The bold- faced quote means no condemnation to the functionally literate .
I wrote "Hamas up to its old tricks of using hospitals as bases of operations" which is the obvious antecedent to "it". A functionally literate person would understand that, unlike you.
Then perhaps you should start.
 
Why is an Israel apologist complaining about a lack of condemnations against Israel?
This is exactly my point. You and your Ilk condemn Israel when it's your friends from Hamas who are committing war crimes by operating from hospitals.

“Your friends from Hamas” is yet another one of your ignorant and despicable slurs. No one here has defended Hamas, and you know it. I only wish the rules here would permit me to tell what I really think of you.
 
What is your take on the Oslo Accords and Netanyahu's role in their being abandoned by Israel?
Oslo had been abandoned by Palestinians when they started the so-called "Second Intifada".
Bullshit.

It was abandoned by Israel when Rabin was assassinated by a radical Zionist, the government of Israel did not cede Area C as it was required to do under the terms of the Accords, and Ehud Barak tried to negotiate a different deal rather than sticking to the deal the Israelis and Palestinians already had.

The Second Intifada started months later when protests against a notorious murderer of Palestinians strolling around the Temple Mount like it belonged to Jews only escalated into a series of increasingly violent confrontations and reprisals, after the Oslo Accords, which would have placed Temple Mount and other sacred sites under joint administration, was abandoned due to the murderous activity and threats from the faction of which that man was a prominent member.

I know you have to defend your bullshit premises in order to get your apologia accepted, but really? You think the Oslo Accords weren’t abandoned when Israel stopped complying with them to appease the murder-y pro-continued Zionist expansion factions?
 
Last edited:
You have yet to show how my interpretation is wrong. The bold- faced quote means no condemnation to the functionally literate .
I wrote "Hamas up to its old tricks of using hospitals as bases of operations" which is the obvious antecedent to "it". A functionally literate person would understand that, unlike you.
A functionally literate reader would read the actual antecedent (in blue) which is about the IDF bombing.

Derec said:
Then perhaps you should start.
Perhaps when I more confident of your communication acuity so as to avoid your truculence. Maybe it’s my age, but I find the underlying viciousness in your perpetual dissatisfaction tedious.
 
Why is an Israel apologist complaining about a lack of condemnations against Israel?
This is exactly my point. You and your Ilk condemn Israel when it's your friends from Hamas who are committing war crimes by operating from hospitals.

“Your friends from Hamas” is yet another one of your ignorant and despicable slurs. No one here has defended Hamas, and you know it. I only wish the rules here would permit me to tell what I really think of you.
Trust me, it doesn't matter. Most people think of Derec the same way you do. I don't, of course - I'm a little more blunt and frankly disappointed he hasn't started a "look we must be outraged at this black person" thread in over 2 months. You know, like he normally does.
 
Do you have some rational reason to think that the Palestinians will not do exactly what they have promised to do repeatedly: genocide? What they have done since long before 1948--Jews would be attacked for not accepting subservient status. You're telling the battered woman to just go back to her husband, it will be fine.
You are ignorant of history and appear determined to remain so.

What source of information on the history of Palestinian Jews before 1948 do you regularly use? Do you just make it up as you go along or did you buy a line of propaganda and like it so much you kept it?

Hopefully Hakeem Jeffries has a much better grasp of the facts, historical and current, and is capable of much better reasoning than what you keep showing.
 
Last edited:
While they are both antisemitic, Jimmy Dore (whose video RVonse actually posted) is on the far left, while Tucker is on the far right. Any similarity between the two is just a testament to the Horseshoe Theory.
I've never seen or listened to Jimmy Dore but as far as I know he went full righty when he split from TYT. The money is far better for right wing talkers.
 
Back
Top Bottom