Please enlighten us because I don't 'understand where it's coming from' if my understanding that it comes from a place of ignorance and bigotry and hatred is incorrect.
I believe that psychopathy is a mental illness. I think it's a mental defect that should not be normalized. I think psychopaths should receive mental health care, and in some cases that might mean that psychopaths may need to be institutionalized for the safety of the rest of society.
I don't
hate psychopaths, nor do I think my view on the treatment of psychopaths is motivated by
bigotry.
Do you think I'm motivated by hatred and bigotry?
I believe that pedophiles are mentally ill. I think that being sexually attracted to prepubescent children is a mental defect and should not be normalized. I think pedophiles should receive mental health care, and in some cases that might mean pedophiles may need to be sterilized or institutionalized for the safety of the rest of society.
I don't
hate pedophiles, and I don't think that viewing pedophilia as a mental illness is
bigotry.
Do you think I'm motivated by hatred and bigotry?
I think that sexual sadists are mentally ill. I think that being turned on by and achieving sexual gratification from causing other people pain is a mental defect and should not be normalized. I think sexual sadists should receive mental health care, and in some cases that might mean that sexual sadists may need to be sterilized or institutionalized for the safety of the rest of society.
I don't hate sexual sadists, and I don't think my viewing sexual sadism as a mental illness is bigotry.
Do you think I'm motivated by hatred and bigotry?
I believe that schizophrenics are mentally ill. I think schizophrenia is a mental defect and should not be normalized. I think schizophrenics should receive mental health care, and in some cases that might mean that schizophrenics may need to be institutionalized for the safety of the rest of society.
I don't hate schizophrenics, and I don't think my view of schizophrenia as a mental illness is bigotry.
Do you think I'm motivated by hatred and bigotry?
Let's stretch this a bit. I believe that people with cross-species identities are mentally ill. I think genuinely believing you're an animal on the inside is a mental defect and should not be normalized. I think people with cross-species identities should receive mental health care, and in some cases that might mean they need to be institutionalized for the safety of themselves and the rest of society.
I don't hate people with cross-species identities, and I don't think my view of cross-species identities as a mental illness is bigotry.
Do you think I'm motivated by hatred and bigotry?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Now.
Provisionally accept that Kirk genuinely believes that transgender people are mentally ill and need mental health treatment. You don't have to believe the same thing - I'm only asking that you accept that Kirk genuinely believes it.
If Kirk genuinely believes that transgender people are mentally ill and need mental health treatment... then it's entirely possible that his view and his statements are motivated by compassion for transgender people as well as care for the rest of society.
Again - you don't have to think transgender people are mentally ill in order to accept that Kirk believes it to be true.
If you can provisionally accept that Kirk believes this, then calling him a bigot motivated by hatred accomplishes nothing at all. It's ineffective, and you're fighting the wrong fight. Were he still alive, I would say that the only effective way to alter his approach is to
challenge his belief, and change his mind.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
You can't deconvert a christian (or any other religious person for that matter) by calling them names and saying they're hateful. The only way you can deconvert them is to successfully convince them that their belief is in error.