I completely understand the frustration of being told you're 'privileged' while you're struggling to make ends meet. However, minorities are also grappling with those same economic challenges—fighting to pay bills, working multiple jobs—while also dealing with additional hurdles like racial bias, underrepresentation, and fewer opportunities due to systemic inequality. It's not about placing blame, but recognizing that income inequality affects us all, with some having to jump additional hurdles. I suppose we could just ignore the other forms of inequality until everyone’s out of the wealth gap— but why on earth would we do that? Economic inequality is huge, but so are the racial, gender, and social inequities that exist alongside it. They all need addressing. This whole "what about us" on the part of working white people is just strange, because any changes that lesson inequality for minorities actually benefit working white people.
Policies like the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which fought racial discrimination but also strengthened workplace protections for all workers. Even The New Deal launched by President Franklin D. Roosevelt (when they stopped discriminating) benefitted everyone. Although I personally believe affirmative action has run its course and its benefits are debated, it undeniably increased diversity in schools and workplaces. Ultimately encouraging economic growth by giving minorities an opportunity to be the better citizens they wanted to be, which benefited everyone, not just minorities. Raising the federal minimum wage, though often seen as benefiting minorities, has also significantly helped working white Americans. Similarly, criminal justice reform, which some argue mainly benefits minorities, actually improves outcomes for everyone impacted by the justice system, regardless of race.
It's not strange. It's a diminution of the things that white people go through too. When you essentially tell someone who's struggling that their struggle isn't real because other people have it worse then the response is going to be a gigantic Fuck
You. And "Fuck you" is what Trump has inspired in these people.
I hate Trump with every fiber of my being. I hate what he's inspired, but what he did tap into was decades worth of dismissive ridicule at the hands of the left.
The vast, vast majority of white people aren't privileged. It's an absurd notion, and no one should be expected to tolerate absurdity of any kind. Throw in actual racism, shocking ignorance, and poor reading skills, and what you're going to get is the hate that Trump has so successfully tapped into.
What these people want is ugly, racist, and delusional, but their "Fuck You" will be satisfactory enough for them should Trump win.
This isn't about civil rights. It's not about any law. It's about understanding that the largest segment of America's population being held accountable for past sins they had nothing to do with. There is an undeniable undercurrent on the left that believes white people should be punished for [Whatever].
I'm 55. I know better now what this denigration of white people is all about, and I understand things much better than when I was 22. But even now when I hear shit about white privilege it can still get under my skin, and I'll be brutally honest: my first thought is Fuck You. I'm quickly able to put it into perspective though. However, a 22 year old kid working his ass off and struggling? He's not going to able to put it into perspective. He's just going to be angry.
While the left is far less dysfunctional than the right, we do have serious unaddressed and willfully malicious issues.
I understand and agree with much of what you're saying about the anger and resentment felt by many white working-class Americans, especially when their struggles are dismissed or when they feel unfairly labeled due to "white privilege." It’s true that nobody wants to be told their difficulties don’t matter just because someone else’s may be greater, and I see how this can lead to a “Fuck you” reaction that Trump tapped into so successfully.
However, it’s important to recognize that these sentiments of being unfairly targeted or marginalized aren’t exclusive to white Americans or those on the right. Many people on the left, especially racial minorities and marginalized groups, feel a similar frustration when they are confronted with the growing visibility of fascist and Nazi-like rhetoric from elements on the far right. This kind of rhetoric poses real dangers for these communities, and it’s understandable why they feel under attack. The fear and anger they experience are rooted in America’s long history of systemic racism and violence against people of color, which has disproportionately affected them.
While I agree that not all white Americans are privileged, and their struggles are real, the history of oppression in this country has been far more brutal and systemic for “out groups,” particularly Black and brown communities. This doesn’t mean the challenges faced by white working-class individuals are any less important, but the context is different. Working-class white Americans may feel like they’re “sailing against the wind” in a changing world, but people of color have been battling systemic inequality for generations in ways that continue to impact their lives today.
Furthermore, just as you express frustration with dismissive attitudes from the left, I also acknowledge that many on the left feel similarly attacked when far-right movements embrace racist or fascist ideologies. This doesn’t mean the majority of conservatives or Republicans agree with those views, but the rhetoric from these extreme elements is still hurtful and harmful, just as dismissing white working-class struggles can be.
So, while I understand the anger many people on the right feel when they're told their struggles are less important, we must also acknowledge that marginalized groups on the left feel similarly disregarded in the face of far-right extremism. Both sides feel like they are not being heard or understood, and that's a significant part of the political tension we’re seeing today. The key is recognizing that these feelings exist across the political spectrum and are deeply rooted in both personal struggles and historical realities.
It's puzzling to me that people view these groups as being at odds when, in reality, actions that benefit one often end up benefiting the other as well, assuming discrimination is kept in check. Take, for example, Ron DeSantis' law against protesters blocking roads. The law is designed to protect all people—regardless of race—who rely on safe and open roadways during protests. However, when it wasn't enforced during the Cuban-American protests against the Cuban government’s economic and political conditions, it didn’t benefit anyone. Selective enforcement undermines the very purpose of the law and highlights the importance of consistent application for the greater good.
That selective enforcement felt like a blatant "fuck you" to Black people, coming directly from a right-leaning politician who enjoys strong support from many white working-class Americans in Florida. It’s no surprise that people on the left look at his voters and respond with a "fuck you" right back. This back-and-forth of frustration only deepens the divide. My message to white hard working American's in Florida is how about not voting for politicians like DeSantis if you don't want to be seen as supporting fascism and racism? Just a thought.¯\_(ツ)_/¯
There are plenty of better options than Trump too. So instead of parading around on TV with MAGA hats and Trump flags while he rambles on about pointless bullshit, they could focus on leaders who actually offer meaningful solutions instead of purely Villainizing fellow Americans.
For example, the left should stop treating wealthy people that way, but the wealthy needs to make it less difficult to stop first.