Harris vs. Demings: Putting VP Contenders to the 'Kaine Test' | RealClearPolitics - how do they compare to Hillary Clinton's VP choice, Tim Kaine?
1. Safe choice. What counts as safe?
Winner: Tie
2. Impressive résumé.
Tim Kaine: Law clerk, lawyer, Richmond VA City Councilmember, Ric Mayor, VA Lt. Governor, VA Gov, Senator
Kamala Harris: San Francisco Deputy District Attorney, SF Assistant DA, SF DA, CA Attorney General, Senator
Val Demings: Orlando FL police officer, Orl police chief, House of Reps
Winner: KH
3. “His geographic and personal story has party-base and general appeal.” Like TK's getting VA's electoral votes as a favorite son.
KH doesn't have much to offer in this department, since CA is safely Democratic.
When Val Demings was made impeachment manager for impeaching Trump, she tweeted
“I am a descendant of slaves, who knew that they would not make it, but dreamed and prayed that one day I would make it. So despite America’s complicated history, my faith is in the Constitution. I’ve enforced the laws, and now I write the laws. Nobody is above the law.”
Winner: VD, because of FL's 29 electoral votes from her being a favorite daughter.
4. “In 2014 Kaine played the Clinton loyalty card, overcompensating for 2008.”
How loyal are KH and VD to JB?
Winner: Tie
5. “Kaine can handle the Bill Clinton problem.”
First, both Harris and Demings are well suited to handle “the Donald Trump problem,” having come from tough law enforcement backgrounds. Therefore, expect that Biden will unleash his running mate as an attack dog while he appears more “presidential.”
But when Trump attacks these women of color, he will need to tread lightly due to heightened racial and gender sensitivities, or he’ll likely suffer further vote loss among suburban women.
Winner: Tie
Second, if elected (and as a former VP) Biden will be prone to offer “expertise and guidance” that both Harris and Demings must navigate. Consequentially, if Biden selects Harris, he might require a “food taster” since the senator appears more power hungry with her own agenda and less likely to accept her president’s “expertise and guidance.”
Winner: VD
Lastly, what about the most famous VP selection criteria adage of "Do no harm"? Between Demings and Harris, the senator’s sharp tongue might cause some “Twitter storms” on the campaign trail.
Winner: VD
Overall winner: KH